Share good ideas and conversation.   Login, Join Us, or Take a Tour!
comment by tvamsisai
tvamsisai  ·  703 days ago  ·  link  ·    ·  parent  ·  post: India's War on Cash

You may ask me questions if you want to know anything specific.

I stay here in Bengaluru, Karnataka, India.




byonic  ·  703 days ago  ·  link  ·  

I would be interested in hearing about life in India in general, especially from the point of view from someone on Hubski. Do you think people in the West, or on Hubski have an accurate idea of what life in India is like?

tvamsisai  ·  702 days ago  ·  link  ·  

Life in India generally is... in a very general sense, about 5-10 years behind what the West is experiencing, in terms of livelihood and technology, depending on which part of the country/city you are in.

    Do you think people in the West, or on Hubski have an accurate idea of what life in India is like?

The second part of your question is quite subjective to which part you would want to know about. Not all stereotypes are true, but most are.

ArtemusBlank  ·  703 days ago  ·  link  ·  

Do you think this experiment is a good idea?

tvamsisai  ·  702 days ago  ·  link  ·  

It's not entirely an open-ended experiment. This has been done previously I hear. Although this time, the scale is massive.

In Soviet Union (1991)

[In India (1946 & 1978)](http://blogs.timesofindia.indiatimes.com/cash-flow/demonetization-in-1946-and-1978-stories-from-the-past/)

snoodog  ·  703 days ago  ·  link  ·  

Is this or is this not a big deal? The locals on Reddit say that the people see this as mostly a positive thing but that it looks scary to outsiders. How has this affected you personally and those around you.

tvamsisai  ·  702 days ago  ·  link  ·  

It is a big deal to have this to have happened now and not before 2008, which would have got India to the same boat as many other developed countries.

It is not as panicky as it is been reported in the news, even the national media is going haywire with it. Most of the newspapers are exaggerating events. I have traveled about 100+ km (~60mi) in the last two days. I've seen a lot of lines going into banks and ATMs. However, all services are much better than normal, only slower due to the volume.

kleinbl00  ·  703 days ago  ·  link  ·  

What's your experience been?

tvamsisai  ·  702 days ago  ·  link  ·  

Being an urban 21-year-old, I do most of my transactions on petty cash for some meals and snacks. Otherwise, for some drinks and most other services I always present them with some form of virtual currency. I hold a debit card, along with PayTM account - the amazing PayPal of India wallet - for completing transactions over Rs. 300 (~$5). I haven't felt any extra heat about the deficiency of cash with me.

They only time I stood to use an ATM, after the announcement, was when my parents were traveling to a small pilgrimage, for which they wanted some emergency cash that they could carry with them. My mother and I went to the neighborhood ATMs which were either not functioning, without any cash available, or already having a long line of people. It was for my good luck that I found an ATM that was just being loaded. I was the 4th person to get into the ATM, later grew to a 40+ person line. But otherwise, I frequently see long lines of more than 50+ in front of any functioning ATM, where ever it may be. Sure, the lines are long, there's no need to panic unless you need a certain amount of cash urgently, which is rare. I can hardly rationally think it through why so many urban dwellers need cash.

The long lines to the banks are also unprecedented as the deposition of 500s and 1000s can be done later when the lines are shorter. Until then we can use the demonetised units at the applicable counters, such as gas stations and grocery stores.

I like the intention of the government. I'm looking forward to the policy changes (GST and UPI) that would ensure that this step would not need to be taken anytime in the future. Only with such policy changes can the objectives of this exercise be met. So my opinions are reserved until the next budget, March 2017.