I would go with:
Guitar: Jimi Hendrix / James Honeyman Scott
Bass: Mike Watt / John Entwhistle
Drums: Mitch Mitchell / Damon Che
Vox: David Bowie / Jim Morrison
You?
Marvin Gaye? That's excellent. Whenever I listen to What's Goin' On?, I just want to scream 'Save the Babies!!' out of my apartment window all day long.
Vox : Ol' Dirty Bastard Guitar : Thurston Moore Drums : Ginger Baker Bass : Carlos D.
VOX: Grace Slick or Robert Plant
Guitar: Eric Clapton
Drums: John Bohnam or Ron Bushy
Bass: John Paul Jones or Roger Glover My God...there are so many other great ones to choose from like bassist Tommy Shannon (Stevie Ray Vaughn group) or Jeff Artabasy.
Jeff Artabasy -Good call, cool guy :) I'd be surprised if anyone has heard of him but I can vouch for his abilities. Plant sure does have some good pipes, doesn't he!
Guitar: Tom Morello
Bass: Bootsy Collins
Drums: Zach Hill
Vox: Jello Biafra or for a different angle entirely
Guitar:Eric Clapton
Bass: Victor Wooten
Drums: Questlove
Vox: Peter Silberman
I'm imagining Bootsy playing like he did on the Praxis album Sacrifist. Heavy, but funky.
Can't really contribute a classic rock list, not really my thing. Here's a list of musicians from the emo revival scene, which I know the best. (Sorry if nobody has any idea what I'm talking about): Vocals: Jack Senff (Merchant Ships, Midwest Pen Pals, William Bonney)
Guitar: Peter Helmis (Algernon Cadwallader)
Lyrics: John Galm (Street Smart Cyclist, Snowing)
Drums: The guy from Dikembe
Bass: The guy from My Heart To Joy
Horbal? I hear about him all the time, and I know he's part of TWIABP and was a part of MHJ but besides that I have no idea what he does.
Vox: John Lennon
Guitar: Nels Cline
Bass: Paul McCartney
Drums: Glenn Kotche I've changed this list like 7 times only to return to this, my first inclination. My two favorite bands.
I know, it would be pretty amazing. It would be cool to get Paul to come play bass with Jeff and the boys. We could get Stirrat to play something else.
We need to put together the Hubski band: http://hubski.com/pub?id=48188, there are a ton of musicians here.
I love Jim O'Rourke, Eureka is one of my favorites. You just inspired me to make this post
Also a great album, to be sure. Eureka, like a lot of music, holds some major nostalgia for me. That kid in HS must have been creepy :)