a thoughtful web.
Good ideas and conversation. No ads, no tracking.   Login or Take a Tour!
comment by NikolaiFyodorov
NikolaiFyodorov  ·  3744 days ago  ·  link  ·    ·  parent  ·  post: Discussion: Why do you stay in the US?

> When I think "France" and "Muslim" I think "banning the hijab" and "race riots." When I think "Denmark" and "Muslim" I think "cartoons of Muhammad." But when I think "United States" and "Muslim" I think about the molotov cocktail some shithead threw through the window of the mosque in my old neighborhood. And I think of the immediate vigil every old white man and old white lady launched around that building. And I think of the flowers and potted plants that occupied the stoop for the next six months, and I think of the rotating watch of old codgers playing checkers on the steps so that the muslims could go to prayers without worrying about some fuckin' inarticulate redneck who thinks "Islam=hate" because he can't think past generalizations. And I think about the fund raiser the neighborhood did to pay for an expanded parking lot rather than bitching about the mosque in city council meetings, and I think about the vigil the mosque held five years later when some other shithead shot up a synagogue.

As an Aussie who's previously lived for a couple of years in Europe and recently spent several weeks in your fine country, I believe this this paragraph sums up your country more aptly than anything else on here.

I reside, allegedly, in the world’s most liveable city. And let me be clear: I know that I live in one of the world’s most liveable cities. That said, I could move to the north east of the United States tomorrow.

You’ve got an optimism and a can-do attitude, a positive sense of entitlement, that seems to be damn near universal amongst your population - an attitude that is not only taken for granted, but is fucking expected of you as a citizen – that just isn’t there in a lot of other countries. It’s a bizarre thing, and a paradox, that I found these attributes as frequently among the obnoxious, flag waving, marine-loving crowd as I did among the vegan, latte sipping crowd to which I belong. Even when you’re at odds with each other I feel as though there are these basic principles you agree on that underpin your success as a country. And you’re all as friendly as fuck.

Sure, you’ve got a lot of problems. Holy shit there’s so much wrong with your police and your prison system and your drug laws. I’d hate to be born a minority in the US. But there’s a lot wrong with every country, and the only reason that you think there’s more wrong with you guys is because you spend more time in the centre of the world’s attention. Look at the treatment of indigenous Australians in the Northern Territory and northern Queensland, or domestic violence and alcoholism in regional NZ, or the eternally alienated welfare class in north east England. We’re all of us rooted to some degree, and these are all countries at the top of the spectrum, as far as standards of development go.

You do need to do something about your health care system, though.





kleinbl00  ·  3744 days ago  ·  link  ·  

    You do need to do something about your health care system, though.

Immediate sweeping changes I would make:

1) A conscript military. Don't want to serve in the military? Americorps. Peace Corps. Medicins sans Frontier. But I want every mother's son to spend 4 years out in the world, with a gun or without, and I want politicians to stop voting other people's kids out into danger.

2) A higher top marginal tax rate. Let's shake a little money loose, shall we, and increase upward generational mobility while we're at it. Capital accumulation is bad for humanity.

3) Nationalization of primary and secondary school budgets and standards.

4) Single-payer healthcare.

5) Abolition of the electoral college.

6) Election finance reform such that 33% of all funds collected must be disbursed to your competitors.

My king-for-the-day list, anyway.

b_b  ·  3744 days ago  ·  link  ·  

    And you’re all as friendly as fuck.

Ha! And if I'm not mistaken, your recent trip was to NYC, no? That's the least friendly place in the USA, as far as I've seen (although I haven't spent much time in Boston). The South is the most friendly, if you're the right kind of person (and I mean white; let's not be euphemistic; I've been to the Deep South many, many times, and I've heard terrible things from otherwise decent-seeming people). The Midwest and West are populated by generally good-natured people, and are fairly inclusive.

What about Australia. I've met Aussies while traveling, and though I've never been there, they always seem like friendly sorts. I've always assumed being former British colonies, that the US and Australia had a similar makeup, culturally speaking.