a thoughtful web.
Good ideas and conversation. No ads, no tracking.   Login or Take a Tour!
comment by kleinbl00
kleinbl00  ·  347 days ago  ·  link  ·    ·  parent  ·  post: Weird article about privilege in The Age. Posting without comment.

The out-of-hospital birth community tends to be full of privileged white women. Most of them cannot support themselves with their work; they rely on spouses to pay their way. Most of them are also feminist, and advocates and allies of disadvantaged communities.

Most of them, however, do not participate in these disadvantaged communities because... well, they're privileged white women.

The past two years have engendered a truly perverse reckoning. Turns out woker-than-thou is a bloodsport.

- An entire graduating class has rendered themselves unhireable because they demanded changes of wokeness. These are all white women, being taught by white women. They forced out three faculty members, but the one they most wanted to force out remains because no one else will do her job for as little money as she makes.

- A minority-focused collective imploded because it didn't hire enough minorities. The founder of the collective was ejected from her professional membership because she did not resign before everyone quit. The professional membership, meanwhile, elected to disband itself because it lacked minority representation.

- Another professional organization asked its leader to resign because she wasn't a minority. No one else has stepped up to lead it (minority or otherwise) thus it has disbanded.

- Still another organization insisted on changes to increase minority participation without having any minority members to participate. Several people were forced to resign because they were not minorities. We are not a large company? But we represent double-digit percentages of the minority involvement in the community and our people sent out an open letter telling everyone to calm the fuck down, not to put too fine a point on it. However, the leadership of that organization doubled down, causing everyone else to resign.


This is, fundamentally, what white guilt looks like: you signal your superiority by espousing concern for the less privileged, but if they aren't around, the only people you can signal to are those exactly like you. Note that it doesn't benefit the less privileged in the first place, nor is there any remedy: when your virtue measurement metric is "zeal" there is no one with the moral standing to put a stop to it other than zealots, and a reduction in zealotry is capitulation.

We've long since decided to hunker down and let it burn out. It is, fundamentally, a cancer of conscience and the only thing you can do is not get any on you. We dealt with it early and often and in retrospect, got out lucky.

But the minority representation in privileged white circles is not going to increase, which is not going to give the woker-than-thous an opportunity to discover the flaws in their approach, which is not going to temper their approach.

And so long as you can demand changes of others rather than changes of yourself, your discomfort at the very real unfairness of the situation can be assuaged without actually fixing anything.

b_b  ·  347 days ago  ·  link  ·  

One party rule always devolves into a race to see who is the most pious. Show Trials were a great example of how that works practically. Those who haven't read up on them may not be aware that only the truest, most prominent communists who fell from grace got a Show Trial. At the trial the person always read a script denouncing themselves as reactionary, or some variation thereof.

Part of America's problem is that we lack true two party rule. Due to geographic sorting, gerrymandering, etc, we have a de facto dual one party system. So it leads to everyone in Oklahoma out-Trumping each other, and everyone in Seattle confessing their eternal sin of whiteness. In places like where I live (Michigan), it's scarcely better, it's just more local, since we don't have a state-wide consensus.

Ideological purity is not a virtue and never will be. I've literally been called a bigot on this very site for expressing the opinion that compromise isn't bad per se. That's the state of play these days. If you can't outflank the guys on your own side, then you're the enemy.