a thoughtful web.
Good ideas and conversation. No ads, no tracking.   Login or Take a Tour!
comment by cgod
cgod  ·  3614 days ago  ·  link  ·    ·  parent  ·  post: Trust your doctor, not Wikipedia, say scientists

Could the fact that this study came out of an Osteopathic college at all effect the analysis of the Wikipedia entries? I really don't know much about Osteopathy beyond that I think they are the guys who get a DO instead of an MD and that the discipline believed or did believe in some kind of "alternative" medicine stuff?

Any thoughts?

Great write up and thanks for taking the time.

I really enjoy looking up my symptoms every time I get sick to find the most outrageously horrible disease that I might have contracted but I never tell my doctor what I've come up with.





JamesTiberiusKirk  ·  3614 days ago  ·  link  ·  

DOs and MDs are effectively equivalent these days. In fact, a relatively big "shake-up" in the medical community is that the two organizations in charge of administrating the residency programs for the pathways will be merging in the coming years. This means that MD graduates will be able to enter DO residencies and vice versa, assuming certain additional requirements are met (the details of which I'm happy to share but which are boring and somewhat esoteric). DOs really should be seen as normal physicians, though - there is no appreciable difference between the two pathways anymore. The historical distinction between the two is that the DO programs include training in "osteopathic manipulative medicine" (OMM), which is essentially additional training in using musculoskeletal manipulation to treat disease. Sounds like voodoo, but it really isn't. There's also the now-historical distinction that DOs traditionally used a more "holistic" approach when treating patients. In the past this absolutely was a difference, but these days MD training has become much more "sensitive" and PC (for lack of a better description), so this is less of a concern than it was in the past. The reason I say the distinction between DOs and MDs is largely titular is that many DOs don't even use OMM in their daily practice; for many, it's simply something seen during school and quickly forgotten. Others see it as very valuable and continue to use it. But they learn the exact same medical science and have the same general training setup as MDs.

Hah, well as a medical trainee, it's just stress-inducing. Minor headache? PROBABLY BRAIN CANCER. Knowledge is not power in this case. Knowledge is just anxiety.

ButterflyEffect  ·  3614 days ago  ·  link  ·  

    ...musculoskeletal manipulation to treat disease. Sounds like voodoo, but it really isn't.

Do you know of any decent resources for reading up on this? I'm interested because I'm taking a "Muscoloskeletal Biomechanics" course in Fall and would enjoy a head start in it.

Seriously great write up above by the way, that's a comment I wish I could share with more people.