a thoughtful web.
Good ideas and conversation. No ads, no tracking.   Login or Take a Tour!
comment by elizabeth
elizabeth  ·  3713 days ago  ·  link  ·    ·  parent  ·  post: The Definitive Guide to Never Watching Woody Allen Again

I watched Blue Jasmine two weeks ago too! I was surprised to see Louis C.K. there, it felt like he was playing himself (like always?).

Are you of the opinion we should separate the creator from their creation? Can we still appreciate Roman Polanski's works? I watched "the pianist" before I knew anything about the pedophilia and the movie is very touching. Can will still read H.P. Lovecraft's novels even if he was a huge racist? I honestly didn't make up my mind yet and would like to know what you smart people of Hubski think about it all.





mk  ·  3712 days ago  ·  link  ·  

    Are you of the opinion we should separate the creator from their creation? Can we still appreciate Roman Polanski's works? I watched "the pianist" before I knew anything about the pedophilia and the movie is very touching.

I can't apply a blanket rule to it. I did see The Pianist, but it was also before I was aware of Polanski's unpaid crime. I will make me much less likely to see another film by him, but I can't say I will boycott for sure. It would depend on the subject matter, and the context. I've read Lovecraft, and would read more. Everyone is guilty of ignorance, and some are victims of time and/or place. Polanski is particularly disgusting because he fled the consequences of his rape where his victim could not. I'd hate to give him any of my money.

I don't like to make hard and fast rules such as "the creator is separate from the creation", because life is invariably more complex, and I am not sure what advantage such a rule would provide. Consistency can be an admirable trait, but not when it's simply for its own sake.

Shortly after seeing Louis CK in Blue Jasmine, I saw him in American Hustle. Almost the same guy.

b_b  ·  3713 days ago  ·  link  ·  

Louis CK is definitely one dimensional as an actor, but that one dimension is good enough that I always love watching him.

As for Woody Allen, I've seen the majority of his movies. He's one of my favorite filmmakers. I want so badly to give him the benefit of the doubt. That's all I can say. I hope that it's not true. If it were proven to be true, I don't know how that would change my opinion of his movies. I still watch Polanski movies from time to time, but always with a bit of scorn. The difference there is that the facts aren't in dispute.