a thoughtful web.
Share good ideas and conversation.   Login or Take a Tour!
comment by user-inactivated
user-inactivated  ·  605 days ago  ·  link  ·    ·  parent  ·  post: Philosophers of Hubski, do you think Justice is a universal constant?

    When we have a good definition of consciousness ask that question again. untill you can ask a monkey about it's motivations, you can't ascribe human concepts to evolved behavior.

If we see reflections of concepts such as altruism in animals, which are themselves reflections of concepts such as Justice and Morality, wouldn't that in some ways point to the idea that Justice is a naturally occurring phenomenon?

    An argument in favor of my point. This all occurs in your head.

Is it though? Would you argue then, that our thoughts and feelings aren't real, and therefore unworthy of consideration and potentially inconsequential?

    Depending on your definitions, it can be said that humans label certain actions and behaviors 'Just' and so 'Justice' exists as a set of behaviors we exhibit. Which I think still supports my point. Thought leads to behavior.

In another light of my previous question about thoughts, if behavior is the consequence of thought, where does that leave us?

    This of course all goes out the window if you bring deity into the question, which I explicitly choose to not do.

I think we're doing just fine viewing things from a secular lens. I like your answers by the way. They're making me think.

I'll tell you what, because I feel like I'm being unfair to you by asking so many questions. I'm gonna take the dog for a walk and when I get back, I'll post my thoughts on the matter and you can ask me questions as well.





kantos  ·  605 days ago  ·  link  ·  

I think this discussion boils down, once again, to what is the definition of justice so that it can be considered a constant to begin with. To that end, you'd be able to answer: what did justice look like in the prehistoric era - an era before humans as we know us, who brought the notion to light for ourselves.

OftenBen  ·  604 days ago  ·  link  ·  

What justice is there when the sun burns out and humans haven't developed the tech to colonize other star systems?

At any time scale other than that of human lives, there is no justice.

Foveaux  ·  603 days ago  ·  link  ·  

Never thought of it like that - which probably says more about me than anything else. But thanks for putting the words down.