a thoughtful web.
Good ideas and conversation. No ads, no tracking.   Login or Take a Tour!
comment by BrainBurner

I don't see how this is a problem, except that some talented writers are held back by their personal circumstances.





mk  ·  3015 days ago  ·  link  ·  

It's a fairly niche issue, but I think the problem she sees is that by avoid discussing the role that financial support can play, new writers might be operating under unrealistic expectations. Given her own circumstances that she describes, she might not have realized how large a role money played in her ability to be a successful writer until she had enough.

BrainBurner  ·  3015 days ago  ·  link  ·  

I see now, thank you! Thanks to 45usp as well :)

45usp  ·  3015 days ago  ·  link  ·  

I believe the author's primary complaint is that it's disingenuous of the exemplified 'success story' authors to pin their successes on 'hard work,' 'remaining childless,' or any other such glib reasoning. In fact their successes are often supported in finance and by community; to claim otherwise provides a false model of success to other would-be [inexperienced] authors who could then make some non-productive and possibly very bad life choices based on that advice. It takes talent to be a successful author, absolutely, but some people have their wheels greased and roads paved while the rest of us creak and bump through.

kleinbl00  ·  3010 days ago  ·  link  ·  

Because success as a professional hinges on remuneration and the act of selling something, and people who are known as authors "supporting" themselves on their writing are held in radically higher esteem than those who write "on the side" but make the majority of their income doing something else.

More than that, The Great Creative Meatgrinder tells talented, impressionable young creatives that if they build it they will come, that talent will win out over mediocrity, that it took you 20 years to become an overnight success, that it's all about strength and perseverance. The Great Creative Meatgrinder does not tell these children that they'll be doing it while asking if you want fries with that while the stories they'll hear will all be about trust fund kids who get a new Macbook every year because uncle Chester loves "having a writer in the family" and drive a two-year-old BMW 7-series because Ivanka hates it when the Fullertons have a newer car than she does. And they'll get to go to meetings at places with $500 bottle service that will sell you five bacon-wrapped dates for $12 because - and here's the other thing they won't tell you - the rich children pick expensive places purely to keep the proles out.

Everybody loves Anne Lamott. Bird by bird. Page by page. It's about the work, which you can do while being divorced, while raising a kid. Few people mention the fact that Anne Lamott started hounding her dad's agent when she was in her teens, and didn't get anything published until said agent eventually got something sold when she was in her early 30s.

Know how many aspiring young writers get an agent that will read their drivel for fifteen fucking years? If you guessed "the ones whose parents have made their agents a lot of money" you didn't need to read this article.