a thoughtful web.
Good ideas and conversation. No ads, no tracking.   Login or Take a Tour!
comment by cgod
cgod  ·  4584 days ago  ·  link  ·    ·  parent  ·  post: Ryan Now Rejects Ayn Rand-Will The Real Paul Ryan Please Come Forward?
You might consider taking her seriously, she has had about 10000 times more impact on American society then any other "philosopher." Maybe Jesus, Plato, Aristotle and the pragmatist are competitive influence wise. I don't know of any philosophical system that really holds up to close examination, at best people try to pretend that they live by or interpret the world in an intellectually consistent manner and fail realize that they are full of shit.

Not a fan of Rand, I think people are a lot more like ants then lions, pretending to be something you are not generally creates unhappy outcomes.





alpha0  ·  4583 days ago  ·  link  ·  
I do not follow philosophers myself, cgod. For the obvious reasons.

    You might consider taking her seriously, she has had about 10000 times more impact on American society then any other "philosopher."

Certainly the corrosive effects should be taken seriously, as one would take poison in the water supply seriously. I certainly respect the right of any to hold an opinion, but do not ask me to universally respect opinions. It really depends on the opinion.

Earlier, due to the OP, found out that Atlas Shrugged enjoys a circulation second only to The Bible. I kept my peace but then your comment set me off reflecting about this. What is interesting about the above fact, that an anti-intellectual civilization such as America's holds the above two books in popular esteem, is very informative:

Both books promote the idea of exceptionalism and both appeal to the popular mindset. In one, the exceptional is held to a requirement of service to his lesser brethren. In the other, the lesser ones are held to be ballast and clay in service of the exceptional individual.

Now it is (somewhat) easy to see why The Bible enjoys wide circulation among the many (after all what sort would not be affected by the sermons of Christ or some of the Psalms?), but the wide circulation of the other is surely worth further reflection.

    I think people are a lot more like ants then lions, pretending to be something you are not generally creates unhappy outcomes.

It is as you say. One should not pretend to be a follower of Christ anymore than one should entertain grandiose notions of heroic efforts and the upholding of the heavens on one's back.

cgod  ·  4583 days ago  ·  link  ·  
She is some scary shit all right, and not a "thinker" to be offhandedly dismissed.

Discounting her significance reminds me of people who called George W Bush and idiot. Who the hell are they to call one of the most successful presidents of all time an idiot. Better to realize that people who hold very different view points from your own can be extremely dangerous and influential.

alpha0  ·  4583 days ago  ·  link  ·