Piss off. Why is the cover of Vanity Fair "prohibited materials?" Bottom line - Chelsea Manning is being punished for having transgender materials in military prison. Those materials include a completely innocuous photograph of a public celebrity. The title is fine.ACLU lawyer tells BuzzFeed News that the charges relate to Manning having prohibited materials in prison, including Caitlyn Jenner’s Vanity Fair cover story.
Among the materials that DiPasquale told BuzzFeed News were confiscated from Manning are The Advocate and Out magazines; an issue of Cosmopolitan with an interview of Manning; Transgender Studies Quarterly; and a novel about transgender issues, A Safe Girl to Love.
According to the petition, the alleged misconduct that led to Manning requesting to speak with her lawyer related to her “sweeping some food onto the floor.” The petition states that a charge of “improper medicine use” resulted from Manning having the expired tube of toothpaste.
The cover isn't a prohibited material, the entire magazine is. Surely you can understand that. Bottom line, Manning is being punished for having contraband in prison. The content of those materials only matters if you're trying to make this into something it's not.
The article has been revised in the past hour. An hour ago, it said she had a rolled-up cover of Vanity Fair, not the entire magazine. And I reiterate: Why is Vanity Fair contraband? "Bottom line", Chelsea Manning is being treated incredibly unfairly by the military penal system. This is an extension of that. I'm not trying to make this into something it's not - we're talking about a person spending the next 30 years in solitary for having a magazine. That's some straight-up North Korea shit right there. If you don't get that, I'm not sure there's any way to make you see it.
It's contraband because they say it's contraband. It doesn't have to make sense to someone outside the system. The article uses the terms "including" and "among" thereby implying there to be more than just these items. Buzzfeed has only highlighted these specific items because that's what brings controversy to the story. It's easily spun as an attack on transgender folks and that's what they want because that's what brings views which turns into money. I don't doubt that Manning is probably being treated more unfairly than other prisoners because of her decision to (not sure of the correct phraseology here) be transgender and the nature of the crimes committed. That's not a fact that I can verify and it doesn't mean I'm right, but it's not hard to imagine that it's happening. It's not even close to North Korea. We're not taking generations and enslaving them in essentially concentration camps. The article and the title here both inspire the reader to have a certain mindset and that is to think that this is an affront to transgender folks, when it's not verified that this is true. Buzzfeed has cherry picked the information they want to use and spun it into an article of half-truths, which is in no way surprising, but it does need to be noted.
It's not like this shit is new. I stand by my title. I will also point out that Chelsea Manning's treatment is closer to North Korea's than, say, yours, thereby "it's not even close to North Korea" in this instance is more hyperbole on your side than on mine.
I encourage you to read up on North Korea's political prisons. Here's a few links that you may find interesting. http://www.theguardian.com/film/2013/sep/19/north-korea-prison-camp-14-documentary http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/asia/a-land-of-unspeakable-atrocities-un-commission-warns-leader-kim-jongun-he-could-face-trial-for-human-rights-abuses-in-north-korea-9134405.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2008/12/10/AR2008121003855.html https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prisons_in_North_Korea There's also a documentary on the subject. I stand by my statement that Manning is facing nothing close to this. Humiliating, inhumane, and illegal, yes. Nothing close to North Korea. I do agree that we need protection for whistleblowers. What that should be, I don't have the expertise to accurately say, but we can't continue to torture people and call ourselves a civilized nation.
I'm curious. I'm not attacking, making assumptions, arguing, or anything in that manner. I've been thinking since yesterday about this comment thread, and have been pondering it objectively. My goal being open-mindedness on my part, and wanting to learn, can I ask you some questions? Have you ever had your door broken down, been dragged out of bed, and victimized in ways you were powerless to stop? Do you have multiple scars on your body as the results of more than 10 years of physical abuse and torture? Have you ever been chased into the street, knocked down into the asphalt, and had your head and stomach repeatedly kicked in? Have you ever had your head slammed into concrete on more than one occasion so hard that you got brain swelling and concussions? Have you ever been thrown onto a sofa and have someone jump on top of you and beat into you while you try to cover your head with your arms to avoid having the bones in your face fractured, while others stood and watched, and told you that you deserved it? Have you been psychologically terrorized for a period greater than 10 years where the mind games, psychological manipulation was so severe your psyche was fractured, you lost all sense of identity and reality, and you split into two? Have you ever been been forced down onto a bed by a member of your family who attempted to rape you? Have you ever, as a child, been shoved into an oven, had the door closed, the oven turned to 425 degrees, and left for more than 15 minutes to cook til your skin turned red til someone realized what'd happened and came to rescue you? Have you ever had people drag tools, knives and needles into your body, while pinning you to the ground, with someone else holding your hands down, by people doing it because they get a kick out of hurting you? Have you ever been chased through a house, cornered, and been grabbed by your hair and hit so hard that your body does a complete 180 and crumples into the wall, blood pouring from your ear? Have you ever been in a state of continual terror, fear for your life, for a period longer than 10 years? Again, no censure, accusations, judgments, I'm merely trying to figure something out.
I'll just leave this here. http://www.takepart.com/article/2015/02/05/why-transgender-women-color-are-so-often-victims-domestic-violence Just one example among thousands upon thousands of transgender people being terrorized, getting the shit beat out of them, murdered, things thrown in their faces, people screaming in their faces... and these are things done in the light of day. You have no idea what a transgender person might be experiencing in prison.