Share good ideas and conversation.   Login, Join Us, or Take a Tour!
comment by thesummerking
thesummerking  ·  1185 days ago  ·  link  ·    ·  parent  ·  post: What Do You Think Would Happen if Black People Began Arming Themselves?

People use People of Color.. how is that different than colored people? Ignorance isn't bliss, it's just ignorance.




arguewithatree  ·  1184 days ago  ·  link  ·  

you're probably long gone now but PoC was chosen by PoC and not assigned to them by white folx so it's different by orders of magnitude

ILikePizza555  ·  1184 days ago  ·  link  ·  

That's the dumbest thing I've ever heard. What, did every colored person in the world go up to the Un and demand that they be referred to as "People of Color"? Otherwise you have no clue if it was" assigned" or not.

Whether you put the adjective before are after the noun makes no difference.

arguewithatree  ·  1184 days ago  ·  link  ·  

Welcome to hubski. Try being less antagonistic if you want to have a conversation. Words and their order absolutely matter, especially in the context of identities.

Via textual analysis, you can trace the usage of terms. Here is a good NPR article that summarizes how the terms have changed. "People of Color" connotates a community, which is why many PoC prefer to use it. Obviously it's not without criticism.

ILikePizza555  ·  1184 days ago  ·  link  ·  

Okay that article says nothing about the term "colored people" being assigned to them. Nor does it say anything about what the difference is.

And how does "People of Color" connotate a community while "colored people" doesn't? You can describe baseball fans as "baseball fans" or "fans of baseball" and it still has the same meaning.

arguewithatree  ·  1184 days ago  ·  link  ·  

last quote of the article:

    "People of color explicitly suggests a social relationship among racial and ethnic minority groups. ... [It is] is a term most often used outside of traditional academic circles, often infused by activist frameworks, but it is slowly replacing terms such as racial and ethnic minorities. ... In the United States in particular, there is a trajectory to the term — from more derogatory terms such as negroes, to colored, to people of color. ... People of color is, however it is viewed, a political term, but it is also a term that allows for a more complex set of identity for the individual — a relational one that is in constant flux."
Salvador Vidal-Ortiz, Encyclopedia of Race, Ethnicity and Society

"Colored people" was used to degrade and ostracize PoC by white people. There is something to be said about putting the noun before the adjective because it brings the definition back to being about the person, not their attribute (ex. person with Autism rather than autistic person is another one I've seen argued). It's about self-designation and reclaiming personhood.

eta: this wound up in my drafts for a long time and goo hit the point pretty well

goo  ·  1184 days ago  ·  link  ·  

The way I've been taught is how the words define you. There is a similar discussion about whether to say "disabled people" or "people with a disability."

The idea is, "people of colour" indicates you are a person first, and being coloured is a secondary feature. "Coloured people" indicates you are first defined as coloured, and as a person after the fact.