a thoughtful web.
Good ideas and conversation. No ads, no tracking.   Login or Take a Tour!
comment by Saouka
Saouka  ·  4061 days ago  ·  link  ·    ·  parent  ·  post: I Was Dead Wrong

|One advantage the U.S. has is that people can go to any doctor that they want to, provided that they have the money

In the UK we currently have a mix and match system of medical care. You can use the NHS for anything you want to and supplement it with Private medical care to get what you want and then jump back to NHS lines.

So whilst I agree that this is an advantage, you can get both benefits and neither issue that way. I think a mix of Private-Public healthcare is the best approach to any system; it allows freedom from being locked into certain medical treatments and it doesn't bankrupt you from medical bills.

You're bang on about people going to the doctor about nothing though, I spent a day with a Nurse in a local surgery for experience and quite a few of the cases were people complaining about nothing at all. Lot of genuine cases too though, I'd rather that risk than someone losing out on healthcare. When I was in the US with my family we saw a minor accident and my Dad immediately went to call 911 to get an ambulance and was urged not to by everyone involved. It was so surreal from our culture that someone had a broken arm and went "I'll sort it out at home" rather than go into hospital for it. It's been weird growing up and having to decide "Is this worth an ambulance" but it'd be so much worse if I had to think "Can I afford an ambulance" on top of that.





humanodon  ·  4061 days ago  ·  link  ·  

Yeah, definitely. Where I live now, it's about $1400 for an ambulance, but in some states/cities, it's much higher.

I think a mix is the right way to go too, but somehow I don't think finding the right mix for the U.S. will be so easily accomplished. It's tempting to want to change everything, but the reality is that when even one thing changes, there are a lot of things that have to adjust. I'm glad that it's an issue that the public is concerned enough about that political action is being taken, but of course this means a whole lot of talking before anything is done. In the meantime, I guess those of us within the States just have to do what we can to stay as healthy as possible until whatever the new reality will be emerges.