a thoughtful web.
Good ideas and conversation. No ads, no tracking.   Login or Take a Tour!
comment by kleinbl00
kleinbl00  ·  4469 days ago  ·  link  ·    ·  parent  ·  post: Do you think we'll achieve immortality before the end of this century?

As I recall, the AMA did a study whereby they said "okay, let's presume we can cure everything that kills people. What happens to the life expectancy?" I can't find it in the amount of time I'm interested in spending, but the answer was something like "we gain an extra 15 years."

There's a real problem with living in a reducing environment. It really fucks with your chemistry.





mk  ·  4469 days ago  ·  link  ·  

I'd like to see the study. The body does have means to repair/correct for oxidative damage, and there are mechanisms by which DNA sequences can be corrected. Also, telemeres lost in cell divisions can be replaced, and epigenetic regulation can be modified or reversed.

One of the best examples of this reverse aging IMHO is cloning with an adult nucleus. It's incredible that just the cytosol alone of an embryo has enough to motivate an adult cell to revert to developmental mechanisms. Immortalized cell lines are a crude example of making cells continue on.

Theortically, there is no component of the body that can't be replaced piecemeal, or any damage that can't be undone. There is truth to the notion that we aren't the same material we were when we were born. The trick is to get the body to make the replacement, and to swap in less corrupted components.

JakobVirgil  ·  4469 days ago  ·  link  ·  

this ax has been in my family for 10 generations the head has been replaced 5 times and the handle 6.

briandmyers  ·  4467 days ago  ·  link  ·  
kleinbl00  ·  4469 days ago  ·  link  ·  

So if you could do me a solid, in 500 words or less, what's changed about the state of the art since Dolly the Sheep? My understanding was that the shortened telomere problem was kind of a full-stop.

I'll see if I can find the study. It may take a bit.

mk  ·  4469 days ago  ·  link  ·  

To be honest, I'm not very up to date on cloning. I could take a look a it. However, here in cancer research we are very familiar with telomorase running amok, where the ends never terminally shorten.

AFAIK one of Dolly's suspected problems was that the telomeres had already substantially shortened, and they either picked up shortening more at that point, or the telemorase wasn't making up for what had already been lost. But all cells can express telomerase with the right cues, and a number of adult cells do. TBH I'd bet that Dolly had a number of other problems due to a previous life that simple nucleic transfer didn't reverse.

Biology is crazy dirty. There rarely seems to be one problem or one solution. Typically the best you can do is to get the body to start doing the thing that you want it to, and let it go with broad guidance. My guess is we will figure out some slick ways to add a few decades, and then a few more, then a few more...

JakobVirgil  ·  4469 days ago  ·  link  ·  

I am a ghost. all of this is a misapplication of Moore's "law" and I think the creation of a faulty metric we call technology. We are treating it as a vector when it is better modeled as a branching bush. It full analogy with the ladder of evolution vs the tree.

briandmyers  ·  4467 days ago  ·  link  ·  

R. Buckminster Fuller said "I seem to be a verb". I think he meant something like this.

I am not this blob of matter; not really. That is a slice, a snapshot of me.

I am a pattern, a knot of information, moving through time. An incredibly complex knot, made of many smaller, microscopic knots, working together.

My parents, who were similar knots, managed to split off tiny portions of their knots or patterns, and combine them into a new knot (actually they did this a lot, but only a few knots survived for a long time; at least four have still not unravelled.

Eventually all knots unravel. Someday we may know enough to prevent it (would that it were so!). All our knots - yours, mine, the cat's - have survived to this day because it is the nature of our knots to tie new knots. This is life itself.

mk  ·  4469 days ago  ·  link  ·  

    I am a ghost.

I saved that link you dropped. I just haven't been able to read it yet. I agree that much futurology is bunk because people extrapolate what they know.

JakobVirgil  ·  4469 days ago  ·  link  ·  

The arrow of history.

b_b  ·  4469 days ago  ·  link  ·  

That's exactly the point I made in a debate with theadvancedapes yesterday: Entropy rules the universe. Period. Exclamation point. End of story. The laws of thermodynamics certainly do not lend themselves to immortality. Medically speaking, we can keep putting more fingers in the dike, but its gonna collapse eventually.

mk  ·  4468 days ago  ·  link  ·  

I agree with that. My interpretation is that we are talking mortality with a lowercase m.