a thoughtful web.
Good ideas and conversation. No ads, no tracking.   Login or Take a Tour!
comment by caeli
caeli  ·  3166 days ago  ·  link  ·    ·  parent  ·  post: How The U.S. Is Neglecting Its Smartest Kids : NPR Ed : NPR

    Meanwhile, screening for gifted programs usually happens in kindergarten, which creates a heavy bias toward those who come from more affluent homes.

There are some really interesting ethnographic studies on reading practices in homes of varying SES and how this affects the early stages of education. Typically, white affluent parents encourage their children to read from a very young age, starting with the building blocks of words and slowly moving up, etc. But children from lower-income households usually don't read as much and thus don't get those "building blocks". But they tend to have much better high-level reasoning and structuring skills than the affluent kids because they're used to orally telling stories with their parents and other kids. The "building blocks" skills the affluent kids have benefit them a lot in the early years, but the poor kids' high-level story structuring skills don't come up in school until later. (A good way to think about this is that affluent kids are very good at answering what, but poorer kids are very good at answering why). But, the poorer kids are classified right off the bat as being low-performing, which leads to a vicious cycle of not being interested in school, and by the time they get to the point where their reasoning/structuring skills become relevant they've fallen pretty far behind. It's really a shame since these kids aren't low-performing, they just have different skills.





user-inactivated  ·  3166 days ago  ·  link  ·  

I'm curious about the studies you mention. I grew up poor, drug abuse, gangs, violence, etc, but I was also encouraged to go to the library, which inspired my love of reading and self-education. Other low income students, broken homes, etc I became friends with in the private schools I got put into later in childhood, they were the same. Do you have an idea of specifics about these studies, in this regard? Does it take into account the people from broken homes and poverty who still managed to excel in school? I'd be interested in data about that specific phenomenon.

caeli  ·  3166 days ago  ·  link  ·  

Yeah, this varies widely of course -- my parents didn't go to college and we were lower middle class but I was an obsessive reader. These are just trends noticed by various ethnographers. The particular study I based my comment off of is a fairly old piece (1982) by Shirley Heath, "What no bedtime story means: Narrative skills at home and school". This is by no means a quantitative, or recent, or widespread, study, but it gets at these issues very well and frames the problem much more eloquently than in my comment for sure! There are a few other studies like this, but this is just a memory from a course I took a couple years ago so I don't have sources immediately available.

There's also the fact that you ended up going to private school, which probably has something to do with your observations; families who stress education enough to send their child to a private school probably also encourage behaviors like reading that play a role in how schools defines success.

user-inactivated  ·  3166 days ago  ·  link  ·  
This comment has been deleted.