a thoughtful web.
Good ideas and conversation. No ads, no tracking.   Login or Take a Tour!
comment
ooli  ·  1963 days ago  ·  link  ·    ·  parent  ·  post: Ben Carlson: Debunking the Silly “Passive is a Bubble” Myth

As the article said : I have ETF shorting the index, Shorting with a x5 leveraged, I have ETF on gold, oil, bonds, whatever I can think of, all less correlated to equity than any active fund.

Probably those ETF trade for far less volume than S&P's ETF but I dont get how The 1st dude (the 2008 short guy) can pretend their is a systematic risk with ETF when he only address the (legitimate) risk of

    "self-reinforcing feedback loop"
of equity's ETF and ignore the ton of others ETF which counter the feedback.

If he only mean we have an irrational equity bull market because of ETF (which are mostly S&P related, volume wise), then he got a point. But it's not "passive is a bublle" it must say "passive is creating the bubble'"and active or passive, you'd better stay away of that artificial bull market