a thoughtful web.
Share good ideas and conversation.   Login or Take a Tour!
kleinbl00  ·  1471 days ago  ·  link  ·    ·  parent  ·  post: The fading American dream: Trends in absolute income mobility since 1940

    I guess my question there is, what if there is a logarithmic curve to real median income growth for a given mix of workers?

My counter-question would be, "what is the significance of the median?" Certainly, if you were going to pick one statistic it's a good one to pick but if you're trying to analyze the whole system and its desirability to all participants, you might want to look at income deciles, for example:

Median income has stagnated for the median since 2000. It's stagnated for the 60th and 70th deciles, too. 80th and 90th? Things are bright. 20th, 30th, 40th? things are in the shit. But take a close look at 10th percentile - straight poverty level - Bush and Clinton were awesome for the poor and it's been pretty much shit ever since.

    Maybe we hit that limit in 1998 and now we're going to be stuck there until a major change.

Put another way, "maybe tax and social policy hamstrung the lower and middle class in 1998 at the expense of the upper class."

This is not a natural system - it is the output of a synthetic system whose inputs are tax and employment policy. It's not a problem Sweden has:

It's a problem Greece has in spades:

So in a sense yes, the numbers reflect the inputs. But in a sense no, those numbers are not "natural."