a thoughtful web.
Good ideas and conversation. No ads, no tracking.   Login or Take a Tour!
comment

The issue of the wall is that it banks on a misunderstanding of border controls. A border patrol and/or inspected border crossings exist in order to prevent a systematic bypassing of international tariffs and controls. The Great Wall of China was not created to keep out Mongolian refugees, it was created to keep out massed Mongolian cavalry. Likewise, the border patrol doesn't exist to keep out individual refugees, it exists to prevent consortiums from violating the border with goods and materiel. A ladder or rope gets an individual across the Great Wall of Trump but is no more effective at preventing a rogue convoy of black market TV or cocaine than a helicopter is. The helicopter, however, costs a lot less.

The porosity of a border is a quantity, not a binary. Some will get across no matter what. The demonstrable utility of the wall flies in the face of the proposed purpose of the wall, which is why most people object to it - it's an expensive and quixotic gesture of no real purpose except to excite the minds of those who don't understand foreign policy.

Which is pretty much Trump's campaign in a nutshell. You call them "shit sandwich" and "giant douche" but the fact remains: "shit sandwich" has made arguably wrong policy decisions based on her worldview and the worldview of those within her sphere. "Giant douche", on the other hand, has no policy, demonstrable or otherwise, and those within his sphere are equally naive as to the function of a modern state. Clinton may have made the wrong choice on Benghazi. Trump doesn't know where Benghazi is.

Yet for you, the fact that "giant douche" comes out ahead because he's untested and quixotic, while "shit sandwich" comes out behind because she's actually demonstrated her position? Is that what you're really saying?

"I like Trump because he's never had to put his money where his mouth is?"

"I like Trump because no record whatsoever is better than a record I disagree with?"

"I like Trump because the offensive shit he wants won't ever come to pass while Clinton might actually accomplish something in office?"