It still boils down to you disregarding a solicited opinion in favor of your personal opinion of a crowdsourced distillation. Particularly when I said the best way to experience Madoka is to go into it blind with no expectations. You can't talk about why you're uncomfortable with all three because you don't know anything about them - you're uncomfortable with your interpretation of Wiki's interpretation of them and you're still placing that second-level distillation above first-hand recommendations that you specifically requested, and it's still a dick move. But sure - explain to me why an anime about a transvestite lounge singer attempting to defeat a world filled with alien sympathizers is A-OK but a deconstruction of Sailor Moon gives you the willies.