Good ideas and conversation. No ads, no tracking. Login or Take a Tour!
kleinbl00 · 3425 days ago · link · · parent · post: What If Authors Were Paid Every Time Someone Turned a Page? Amazon is about to find out.
You're arguing that Harry Potter owes a lot to TH White. Sure, obviously. That doesn't make it derivative of The Once And Future King. "Derivative" means, at its most basic, "imitative in a negative way." Having written 500 words or more on how Harry Potter is not the most amazing new thing under the sun, I think we can stipulate that JK Rowling owes a lot to basic literary tradition. But that's a long damn way from being "derivative pap."