Thanks for sharing this, you have some really valid criticisms in there, some of which I noticed while watching the film, but was able to set aside for the sake of enjoyment. Most notable, the fact that they conveniently "yell" there plans loudly enough that he can hear them through the window and the "from the hilltop" "pull my finger" death scene that he can conveniently see.

Also, yes it's true that the whole "Human Project" thing is weak and the cousin would seem a viable option, given his money and status. However, I think the movie works on the level of metaphor better than the level of realism. If you try to think of it in terms of "this could or couldn't" happen, it breaks down pretty quickly.

I enjoyed it, but I wouldn't hold it up as the end all/be all for films. I'd recommend it to someone to see though.

As for his motivation being money and why would he take the baby all the way without it etc... ? I think the answer is his memory of begin a father. He has a paternal intuition that kicks in.

Thanks for sharing this KB, I'll not expect a response as you've clearly put in your time already debating this film. Again, I think you make some valid criticisms.

What did you think of the cinematography?

Also, I too enjoyed the Floyd references. That pig was anything but subtle though.