a thoughtful web.
Good ideas and conversation. No ads, no tracking.   Login or Take a Tour!
comment by am_Unition
am_Unition  ·  3323 days ago  ·  link  ·    ·  parent  ·  post: The aliens are silent because they're dead

It's possible, but I personally believe that any advanced aliens would have already been alerted to our existence. Wishful thinking, perhaps. So why haven't we heard anything from them? The same reason you don't drive halfway around the world to yell at a mound of fire ants about assimilating into the global economy.

Edit: To elaborate (Edit2: Actually, mk managed to say this same thing with fewer words) - perhaps the phase of time between evolving human-level "intelligence", but still shy of the technology required to completely encrypt all electromagnetic communication/radiation* (for self defense) is typically very short, on the timescale of the universe. Maybe most civilizations completely ruin their home planet before developing the means to colonize elsewhere. And I'm not contradicting the article's premise, just pointing out that there are perhaps a huge number of unaccounted factors at play.

*Just had a pretty decent idea for a protocol on this.





ooli  ·  3322 days ago  ·  link  ·  

Your argument for the no-contact is :

-Alien are way beyond us (ants). But hey, we study ants at least. That's called the 'Zoo scenario' (we're the pet).

Some other arguments are:

-They stay in their Dyson sphere, happy with their lives without any need to conquer the galaxy.

-They communicate by means beyond our understanding (Snowden used that argument by saying that aliens use encryption)

- We're part of the alien: Earth was randomly seeded with life because aliens found it the fastest way to populate the galaxy.

The best one:

- Everyone stay silent, because there are some killer robots or something out there. (Ancient Aliens need a ton of episodes about that)

Other arguments are mostly about death:

-Life is ultra rare

-Life is fragile ( this article argument's)

-Sentience is doomed (to kill itself before take off)

All this is so fun