a thoughtful web.
Good ideas and conversation. No ads, no tracking.   Login or Take a Tour!
comment by humanodon

If someone wants to begin doing something, there is always the desire to have it come out well the first time. Deciding to make substitutions to a bread recipe the first time around might not be the best way to achieve the goal. There are lots of bread recipes that don't call for bread flour (and I think it's the same price as AP).





_refugee_  ·  4154 days ago  ·  link  ·  

Absolutely! And I did see zebra2 also say he has had mixed results with different types of flour, including Gold's - even though I haven't had bad results. So I'm sure everyone's mileage varies.

I really hate making trips for the grocery store for just one thing. It's funny, when I was learning how to drive I loved doing so and my mother would send me out to Acme as many as three times in a day for something she'd forgot. Now it's more of a hassle. And honestly, in my experience, I haven't noted a big difference, although I will also say that if I know I'm baking bread I'll buy King Arthur's knowing it has a higher protein content compared to other flours, even though it's not technically bread flour.

Personally, I have not noticed a signficant difference when I don't use bread flour - unless I use White Lily.

humanodon  ·  4154 days ago  ·  link  ·  

I notice that when I use King Arthur AP for biscuits, I really have to handle the dough as little as possible-- like, get the flour sandy, incorporate the buttermilk, make a ball, then pat it out and fold maybe 3 times and that's it, or else they come out leathery. White Lily isn't widely available here, unfortunately . . .

_refugee_  ·  4154 days ago  ·  link  ·  

My mother swears by White Lily for biscuits and general baking. It's not available in our area either so she gets our Southern relatives to bring it up for her whenever they make a trip. :)