a thoughtful web.
Good ideas and conversation. No ads, no tracking.   Login or Take a Tour!
comment

    You literally held DS9 to be worse than Brooklyn 99. And your justification is "the writing sucks and the writers suck."

I mean, I kind of want to avoid further arguing, but yeah. I really feel that.

    Given an hour in which everything about the world is known (Brooklyn 99) or an hour in which a new concept must be explained, explored and then resolved (DS9), much less of the hour can be devoted to the decorum you so crave.

I could have sworn I talked about that, but looking back at my ranting, I must have left that out. So I'll say I completely acknowledge that westerns and sitcoms and dramas and the like have the luxury of not being bogged down by world building. They have both a visual as well as a literal vocabulary that we're all familiar with so the ball can get rolling much quicker. That said, maybe part of the flaw in sci-fi writing is that the writers are a bit too worried about world building sometimes? I mean, how hard is it to say "It's a fucking spaceship with anti-matter engines. We're not going to take the time to explain it because that's what it is and fucking deal with it so we can get on to addressing whether or not it's morally acceptable to tell this stone age civilization that gladiatorial combat is immoral." I mean, at this point, I'm beating a dead horse but I'm honestly not concerned about space ships. I'm concerned about characters being compelling and realistic.

    There's a reason 99% of it these days is fuckin' superhero dreck.

Dude. Maybe it's because DS9 is literally brand new to me, but I would easily watch it, frustrations and all, over the majority of the shit being pushed by Marvel and DC right now. Shit, it's getting to the point where I think I'm gonna stop keeping track of The Valiant Universe. I don't know if you're actively reading anything right now, I'm assuming you're not, but let me tell you, it's baaad.

    But most people wouldn't accuse science fiction of being crap but Kaiju films of being great.

    That's all you.

I know what tickles my imagination. :)