a thoughtful web.
Good ideas and conversation. No ads, no tracking.   Login or Take a Tour!
comment
shiranaihito  ·  3223 days ago  ·  link  ·    ·  parent  ·  post: The Repugnant Conclusion

    The problem with the NAP is that "aggression" is not particularly well-defined.

It's often referred to as "the initiation of the use of force", which covers intimidation/coercion and physical violence of course. That's clear enough. Everyone knows when they're being coerced.

    If I find someone in cardiac arrest lying on the sidewalk, I may be "aggressing" them (even breaking their ribs) by performing CPR

Obviously your intent matters too. Genuinely trying to help someone can't sanely be considered immoral.

    the NAP isn't close to useful when it comes to answering textbook moral cases like the Trolley Problem

So what? It can be applied to 100% of what happens in ordinary, everyday life. What does a theoretical scenario like the Trolley Problem matter with regard to real life and the kind of situations you actually encounter?