a thoughtful web.
Good ideas and conversation. No ads, no tracking.   Login or Take a Tour!
comment
alpha0  ·  4511 days ago  ·  link  ·    ·  parent  ·  post: The Real Tragedy of Euro
That's just zerohedge's "tyler" giving his read of the pdf.

There is a bit of conflation here in your equating the national intent and the actual acts by the ruling classes of those nations. Specifically, you are accepting the superficial state of affair e.g. that the said ruling class of "PIIGS" are nationalists and were not implementing a plan designed to lead their nations to this point, where elected leaders of these nations are replaced with technocrats of the Financial System.

A very interesting thing I have noted in my (limited) travels is that the upper classes typically have greater affinity and ties with their peers in other nations than with the unwashed of their own nation. They speak the same language and have shared concerns regarding their precarious position in regards to the subject classes. It is natural for them to flock together and it is not unreasonable to note that it is possible for them to find a synergetic solution to a common concern.

So there remains the possibility that back room discussions between ruling elite of various "southern" European states and their peers from the dominant powers in Europe regarding the effort of preventing another European WW (with the implied threat of use of force by the dominant powers). & So, perhaps, they sold out their countries in order to assure the continuity of their privileged socio-economical position; that they would lose political power was a given based on the practical facts of the matter: they were not in a position to challenge the dominant European powers and might as well make the best in face of the inevitable.

Anyway, I would hope you do agree that even when superficially considered, the current Brussels centered system is egregiously undemocratic and has repeatedly ignored clear expressions of "NO" by various European people, so the above thought is not entirely errant (or imo should not be dismissed at hand) if one considers the political attitude of the EUrocrats to date. The foundation of your POV is the soundness of the political process that gave rise to EU. One can certainly challenge that assumption based on historic facts to date.

Something to think about ...