a thoughtful web.
Good ideas and conversation. No ads, no tracking.   Login or Take a Tour!
comment by galen
galen  ·  3545 days ago  ·  link  ·    ·  parent  ·  post: Let's talk about two things they say never to talk about:

    What has changed about them through the process of exiting the womb that differentiates them from how they were an hour before, as a fetus. The only thing I can think of is physical location, changing from in to out of the womb.

They're a fully formed, totally independent person. I guess it's the independence that matters most to me. So maybe it makes sense to say a life starts at the cutting of the umbilical cord? I hadn't really thought about that before.





fireballs619  ·  3545 days ago  ·  link  ·  

In what way do you see them as independent? I concede that they can breath on their own, but there's not much else a newborn can do on its own. A baby right out of the womb certainly can't provide for itself and will likely die if left alone. How is it more independent now than before?

With regards to the umbilical cord, would you consider killing a baby who is out of the womb yet still attached via this cord as morally the same as taking the morning after pill?

galen  ·  3545 days ago  ·  link  ·  

    In what way do you see them as independent?

Physically. They're no longer physically attached to their mothers.

    With regards to the umbilical cord, would you consider killing a baby who is out of the womb yet still attached via this cord as morally the same as taking the morning after pill?

Probably not. But I'm still just considering the idea that a baby attached at the umbilical cord isn't alive yet. Actually, y'know what, get back to me on this in the morning. I need some time to think.