a thoughtful web.
commentspostsbadges
Good ideas and conversation. No ads, no tracking.   Login or Take a Tour!
The dilemma of the good
The dilemma of the good  ·  2
walther1978  ·  3855 days ago
waltherpragerandphilosophy1.blogspot.com  ·  #ethics  ·  #ethics.walther1978  ·  #philosophy

tweet  ·  html
basic link:
<a href="https://hubski.com//pub/205810">Discuss this on Hubski.</a>
new tab link:
<a onclick="_blank" href="javascript:L3f7=window.open('https://hubski.com//pub/205810');">Discuss this on Hubski.</a>
markup tips  ·  0

Text surrounded by asterisks (*) is italicized.

Text surrounded by plus signs (+) is bolded.

Text surrounded by vertical bars (|) is quoted. If you double-click a paragraph, it will be quoted.

Text surrounded by tildes (~) is blocked out.

Symbols such as *, +, |, and ~ can be used literally by placed a \ in front of the text.

A user's name surrounded by at signs (@) links to their profile, and the user is notified that you mentioned them.

A word surrounded by hash signs (#) becomes a tag and links to posts with that tag.

Text after a blank line that is indented by two or more spaces is reproduced verbatim in a different font.

URLs become links. However, new users cannot post links in comments.

Hubski URLS become embedded cards, displaying information about the post or comment.

Text can link to URLs by using the following format: [linked text](http://theurl.com)

Youtube, Vimeo, Soundcloud, Twitter, and Spotify urls will embed the content automatically.

Image URLs (.png, .tif, .gif, and .jpg) will embed automatically.



Kerem  ·  3842 days ago  ·  link  ·  

I've just read this short article twice to understand it and here are my notes:

Firstly, "Good" is always written alone, denoting a way of being, a domain or a position. Asymetrically "Bad" is never written alone, it is always mentioned as "bad deeds" or "being bad" throughout the article. Therefore, the author passifies the "Good" while mobilizing the bad. This asymmetrical approach as traced in wordings firstly rests the whole discussion on shaky ground. Where are the good deeds in the argument? Is good merely a position?

Secondly, is the whole argument merely a suggestion on how difficult it may appear to a person to become good as opposed to easily being bad? Are we being told the occasional performance of bad-deeds are a good comfort zone, in comparison to endless self-sacrifice of becoming good?

My two mere suggestions to the author:

- If a person wants to argue or a make a statement on such fragile and widely misinterpreted grounds such as good and bad, he/she should really put in the utmost effort to create a most plain, straightforward language serving a well-defined set of statements. This article fails to do so.

- To deal with good and bad, and to rest it on very solid ground, I may suggest philosophy of Spinoza to the author. Having understood such a structured approach, one can proceed to deal with the matter in a much more structured methodology.

+discuss

markup tips  ·  0

Text surrounded by asterisks (*) is italicized.

Text surrounded by plus signs (+) is bolded.

Text surrounded by vertical bars (|) is quoted. If you double-click a paragraph, it will be quoted.

Text surrounded by tildes (~) is blocked out.

Symbols such as *, +, |, and ~ can be used literally by placed a \ in front of the text.

A user's name surrounded by at signs (@) links to their profile, and the user is notified that you mentioned them.

A word surrounded by hash signs (#) becomes a tag and links to posts with that tag.

Text after a blank line that is indented by two or more spaces is reproduced verbatim in a different font.

URLs become links. However, new users cannot post links in comments.

Hubski URLS become embedded cards, displaying information about the post or comment.

Text can link to URLs by using the following format: [linked text](http://theurl.com)

Youtube, Vimeo, Soundcloud, Twitter, and Spotify urls will embed the content automatically.

Image URLs (.png, .tif, .gif, and .jpg) will embed automatically.



+discuss
bioemerl  ·  3854 days ago  ·  link  ·  

I find that all of these odd inconsistencies and strange-effects of calling people bad or good is just because there is no such thing as being either. It's like when you see any subject riddled with questions that are not explained and have these convoluted work-arounds for everything, the most easy solution is that the foundation was built in a swamp.

+discuss

markup tips  ·  0

Text surrounded by asterisks (*) is italicized.

Text surrounded by plus signs (+) is bolded.

Text surrounded by vertical bars (|) is quoted. If you double-click a paragraph, it will be quoted.

Text surrounded by tildes (~) is blocked out.

Symbols such as *, +, |, and ~ can be used literally by placed a \ in front of the text.

A user's name surrounded by at signs (@) links to their profile, and the user is notified that you mentioned them.

A word surrounded by hash signs (#) becomes a tag and links to posts with that tag.

Text after a blank line that is indented by two or more spaces is reproduced verbatim in a different font.

URLs become links. However, new users cannot post links in comments.

Hubski URLS become embedded cards, displaying information about the post or comment.

Text can link to URLs by using the following format: [linked text](http://theurl.com)

Youtube, Vimeo, Soundcloud, Twitter, and Spotify urls will embed the content automatically.

Image URLs (.png, .tif, .gif, and .jpg) will embed automatically.



+discuss
about
tutorial
faq
rss
tmi
random
privacy & terms
weather
donate
login