a thoughtful web.
commentspostsbadges
Good ideas and conversation. No ads, no tracking.   Login or Take a Tour!
Did Hobbits Actually Exist?!
Did Hobbits Actually Exist?!  ·  1
theadvancedapes  ·  4198 days ago
theadvancedapes.com  ·  #anthropology  ·  #anthropology.theadvancedapes  ·  #hobbits

tweet  ·  html
basic link:
<a href="https://hubski.com//pub/143576">Discuss this on Hubski.</a>
new tab link:
<a onclick="_blank" href="javascript:L3f7=window.open('https://hubski.com//pub/143576');">Discuss this on Hubski.</a>
markup tips  ·  0

Text surrounded by asterisks (*) is italicized.

Text surrounded by plus signs (+) is bolded.

Text surrounded by vertical bars (|) is quoted. If you double-click a paragraph, it will be quoted.

Text surrounded by tildes (~) is blocked out.

Symbols such as *, +, |, and ~ can be used literally by placed a \ in front of the text.

A user's name surrounded by at signs (@) links to their profile, and the user is notified that you mentioned them.

A word surrounded by hash signs (#) becomes a tag and links to posts with that tag.

Text after a blank line that is indented by two or more spaces is reproduced verbatim in a different font.

URLs become links. However, new users cannot post links in comments.

Hubski URLS become embedded cards, displaying information about the post or comment.

Text can link to URLs by using the following format: [linked text](http://theurl.com)

Youtube, Vimeo, Soundcloud, Twitter, and Spotify urls will embed the content automatically.

Image URLs (.png, .tif, .gif, and .jpg) will embed automatically.


mirrored on: theadvancedapes.com

SteveMcK82  ·  4128 days ago  ·  link  ·  

Hey Cadell, do you disagree, or are you not aware of the possibility that they may have coexisted with modern humans? Apparently the indigenous humans of the area have a complex mythology of what they call "Ebu Gogo" that sounds just like our Homo floresiensis!

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homo_floresiensis

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ebu_Gogo

I have to wonder if similar coexisting homo sub-species are responsible for other similar myths, possibly even European myths about Fairies, hobbits, goblins, etc!

Obviously most evidence of these things is wiped out by time, and if these sub-species co-existed, I'm sure they would not have been generally friendly toward Homo Sapiens, as Homo Sapiens would be their greatest threat and competition. They would probably have avoided Homo Sapiens as much as possible, which could lead to their mythological status, as early Homo Sapiens may have anthropomorphized far too much into the fleeting glimpses and interactions.

Specifically, I was fascinated by the specific part of the above Ebu Gogo mythology that references them kidnapping human children! That is also a common part of Fairy/Goblin/Hobbit myth.

Apparently in the Ebu Gogo mythology, they stole human children in an attempt to force them to teach them how to cook and use fire! (In the tales the human children always manage to outsmart them and escape.)

Can you imagine? If there were competing and co-existing subspecies of Hominids one can definitely imagine a group without fire ability being intelligent enough to plan and execute a kidnapping raid in an attempt to gain that ability.

Which if the tales are true, had the opposite effect of Homo Sapiens counter raiding and exterminating them eventually.

But I have read enough mythology, and fiction based on mythology to recognize how common in myth humanoid like creatures who kidnap human children for various reasons, ranging from benign, to playful, to malignant are.

This Ebu Gogo myth that comes from PRECISELY the same area where Homo floresiensis was discovered could be that link!

+discuss

markup tips  ·  0

Text surrounded by asterisks (*) is italicized.

Text surrounded by plus signs (+) is bolded.

Text surrounded by vertical bars (|) is quoted. If you double-click a paragraph, it will be quoted.

Text surrounded by tildes (~) is blocked out.

Symbols such as *, +, |, and ~ can be used literally by placed a \ in front of the text.

A user's name surrounded by at signs (@) links to their profile, and the user is notified that you mentioned them.

A word surrounded by hash signs (#) becomes a tag and links to posts with that tag.

Text after a blank line that is indented by two or more spaces is reproduced verbatim in a different font.

URLs become links. However, new users cannot post links in comments.

Hubski URLS become embedded cards, displaying information about the post or comment.

Text can link to URLs by using the following format: [linked text](http://theurl.com)

Youtube, Vimeo, Soundcloud, Twitter, and Spotify urls will embed the content automatically.

Image URLs (.png, .tif, .gif, and .jpg) will embed automatically.



+discuss
about
tutorial
faq
rss
tmi
random
privacy & terms
weather
donate
login