a thoughtful web.
Good ideas and conversation. No ads, no tracking.   Login or Take a Tour!
comment
kleinbl00  ·  3535 days ago  ·  link  ·    ·  parent  ·  post: Tacoma Police Caught Employing PRISM lite.

Well... to be fair:

1) It's a wire-tapping device, not "PRISM lite."

2) It works by being in physical proximity of your target, jamming the nearest tower, spoofing the network and acting as a relay for cell phone traffic to/from that tower.

3) They're not exactly uncommon.

4) They formed a major plot device of Season 4 of The Wire, back in 2007.

5) Their functionality is so simple and obvious that their patents have been vacated in England.

6) It's not even the cops' fault they didn't disclose everything.

7) They actually cost more than an MRAP or other military cast-off (and have demonstrably better applicability in law enforcement)

8) You and I both know that the Tacoma News Tribune is an out-and-out rag and always has been. They didn't even really start covering David Brame until they were doing retrospectives. (for those of you not local to the PNW, it's quite a story).

So. Yeah, wiretapping. But I've never seen any evidence that Stingrays are more than a localized violation of unlawful search and seizure. If you want to use anything you get out of one you need a wiretapping warrant, same as it ever was. Does it potentially scoop up other cell conversations? Yeah, but it's not a dragnet device like anything associated with the NSA is. It's not a data collection device, it's a data interception device. You need a target before you haul it out of the storage shed.