a thoughtful web.
Good ideas and conversation. No ads, no tracking.   Login or Take a Tour!
comment by Devac
Devac  ·  437 days ago  ·  link  ·    ·  parent  ·  post: What are you Reading? Number who knows

Have you read any of those Dark Imperium books post-Guilliman's awakening? HH grew lukewarm for me, but those new developments turned my head a bit. I don't care about spoilers, but only know the broad strokes so far.

Bram Stoker's Dracula, because it's embarrassing I didn't yet. So far, even though it's a very uneven burn, I like it more than any of the adaptations.

Danielle Cybulskie's How to Live Like a Monk, which, despite the title, is more about how monastics dealt with their life of deprivation, what they did for mental health, how they mitigated burnout, and more. Even though the author is a medievalist historian, it's a very light and approachable read. It's respectable to monks, but secular in lessons learned if that's your worry.

I've been trying to left-side read a couple Loebs', but my vocab isn't there yet. Damn you, Cicero, and your septuple-level puns!





OftenBen  ·  434 days ago  ·  link  ·  

    Have you read any of those Dark Imperium books post-Guilliman's awakening?

Yup. I wanted to enjoy them, and certainly enjoyed parts. The more perspective we get from guys like Frater Mathieu and other mortals the better. But overall I felt they were pretty bland. Ultrasmurfs versus Plague Bois is only entertaining for so long. By contrast I thought Spears of the Emperor was AMAZING and is what more warhammer novels should strive towards, specifically because of its emphasis on the relationship between transhumans and mortals.

    HH grew lukewarm for me, but those new developments turned my head a bit. I don't care about spoilers, but only know the broad strokes so far.

The Horus Heresy for me is best enjoyed as a series of moments, vignettes. I LOVE the Siege of Terra series so far specifically because it takes the broad strokes that were fated to happen and gives context to the big events. I will agree though that there's lots to slog through before you get to the juicy bits.

Overall I'm pretty happy with the direction GW is taking with the franchise, mostly because they seem to be a lot more free with the IP and there's lots of other good content out there. Hammer and Bolter the TV show has been a pretty big smash hit amongst the fandom and I'm loving the Warhammer 40k: Darktide game. It's a bit barebones but the developers are committed to supporting it for a while, and its core gameplay loop is fun for me.

Cybulskie's book sounds interesting. I like that kind of side-view take on history. I may add it to my list once I'm done with War and Peace and Buddenbrooks.

Devac  ·  434 days ago  ·  link  ·  

    I will agree though that there's lots to slog through before you get to the juicy bits.

Sometimes a painful slog for exceptional bits. The setting and story are fun, but... eh, you know how in LotR, the everyone's favourite encounter with Balrog is about the same length as Tolkien yammering about brambles on a footpath or which capezios Legolas donned that day? Same thing here. I kinda just moved to reading excerpts on r/40klore or running wiki articles through TTS while doing something else, only picking up a book on recommendation or because synopsis/excerpt made me curious.

I will read Spears and Siege one of those weekends, though. You're not the first person praising them for what I like (mortal/ooutsider perspective), and they sound good by synopsis alone, but that's a push I needed. Thanks!

OftenBen  ·  428 days ago  ·  link  ·  

If you're going to pick one, go with Spears.