a thoughtful web.
Good ideas and conversation. No ads, no tracking.   Login or Take a Tour!
comment by b_b
b_b  ·  1387 days ago  ·  link  ·    ·  parent  ·  post: "It is rotting American democracy from the inside out."

I remember being taught about the EC for the first time. The lesson was basically, "Did you know that we don't actually vote for the President? We actually vote for Electors who elect the president! But don't worry, kids, it's a formality. The chances of a president winning the EC and losing the popular vote are so remote as to not even be discussed." That would have been in like 1992, let's say. I got to vote for president for the first time in 2000, the same year I graduated high school and turned 18. So I have lived a mere 40% of my adult life under a president who won by popular assent.

Making the EC moot is far easier than abolishing it, since the former only requires a change in state laws and the latter a constitutional amendment. The 270 compact would de facto abolish the EC overnight. I hope that if there's a blue tidal wave at the state level this fall, that it would be on the agenda of many state legislators. The recent SCOTUS ruling is actually a huge win for the 270 Compact, since it would obviate any faithless electors from saying, e.g., "I'm voting how OH voted, not how NY voted, fuck you." A 9-0 ruling also makes GOP court challenges to its inception a hard sell. So I don't think the ruling on its own is that bad. It's a simple plain reading of law, and it's not SCOTUS's fault the law is dumb.

Liberal activists have put a lot of effort into passing redistricting commission laws that make it harder to gerrymander House seats, and they've had a lot of success pursuing that goal in swing states. They have proven that they can take their case to the people, so I hope they'll fight hard for this change, too. I'd throw money at any group trying to get that shit on the ballot.





kleinbl00  ·  1387 days ago  ·  link  ·  

Seventh grade we did reports on something involving government. Kid stood up and told us about the electoral college. We called him a liar. Dude sat there smiling while the teacher let us know that no, children, your vote doesn't count worth a shit, never has, never will, and that's why we were about to see Michael Dukakis spend every tuesday in Vermont but the last president to visit our state was Kennedy.

Let's not mince words; the Senate was a compromise.

b_b  ·  1387 days ago  ·  link  ·  

The Senate was a horrible compromise, but one, I'm afraid, we're stuck with. I think many people would be amazed to learn that there are two things in the Constitution that cannot be changed by any mechanism. The first is moot, since it said that no one could make any changes to slavery for 20 years after ratification. That is why it took 20 years to ban the international slave trade. The other is that the voting power of any given state in the Senate can only be changed by assent of the state whose power is to be changed, which is basically everyone, because it's not like if you change one state's number of senators, you don't affect the relative power of everyone else. So 100% of people in 49 states could all sign up for an amendment that says, "WHY THE FUCK DOES WYOMING GET 2 SENATORS?", and Wyoming just gets to shrug.

user-inactivated  ·  1387 days ago  ·  link  ·  
This comment has been deleted.
ilex  ·  1387 days ago  ·  link  ·  

Look, someone has to represent the cows in Congress, otherwise you get too many pork barrel bills.