a thoughtful web.
Good ideas and conversation. No ads, no tracking.   Login or Take a Tour!
comment by thenewgreen
thenewgreen  ·  4427 days ago  ·  link  ·    ·  parent  ·  post: A 1-star, unfiltered user review of Yelp
I enjoyed reading this. I recently used Yelp, when traveling for work to determine which sushi restaurant I should go to. I ended up at a Hibachi restaurant that has a sushi bar tucked away in the corner. It was apparent that sushi was an afterthought to them, and it showed. Yuck. But it had a very high Yelp score.

I think the authors suggestions are valid. I particularly like:

    3. Give businesses a chance to post comments or respond at the top of their Yelp page where the public can read it before going to the reviews.

Why not? If you're going to use these businesses as the crux of your own, the least you could do is give them a voice. As for forcing them to advertise with you in order to address their concerns or share information with them, he's right that IS extortion.

Unfortunately, his suggestion that businesses be able to opt out (even thought they never opted in) will not solve the problem. Most consumers would just see the "opting out" as admission of guilt. -they must be a really crappy restaurant if they're afraid to show their Yelp score. -Not saying that's right, but that is how it would be popularly received.

By the way, when I got back to my hotel and told the woman at the desk where I had sushi, she smiled and said "you should have asked me". -She, of course, was right.