a thoughtful web.
Good ideas and conversation. No ads, no tracking.   Login or Take a Tour!
comment by acyclicks
acyclicks  ·  3615 days ago  ·  link  ·    ·  parent  ·  post: Ask Ethan #73: The Multiverse and you — Starts With A Bang! — Medium

So, I learned a lot from this article about the expansion and origin of the universe, but his understanding of many-worlds / multiverse seems a little off.

    And if the Universes are all the same as one another as far as physical laws go, and if the number of these Universes is truly infinite, and if the many-world interpretation of quantum mechanics is completely valid, does that mean that there are parallel Universes out there, where everything in it evolved exactly the same as our own Universe did, except one tiny quantum outcome was different?

The talk was by Max Tegmark, and Tegmark's multiverse model covers several layers of multiverses, ranging from highly-probable to highly-speculative. The article only talks about the level I multiverse: space outside our observable universe. Level II is a more traditional multiverse, with different universes arising from different big-bang events.

The many-worlds interpretation doesn't come in play until Level III, and has nothing to do with the expansion of space. As I understand it, the many-worlds interpretation suggests that any time a quantum event might happen, the universe splits in two. The event occurs in one universe, and doesn't in the other. This is the level where you get crazy terrifying effects like quantum immortality.

Level IV is basically platonic realism, where anything that is possible exists. In Tegmark's version, "anything that is possible" is replaced with "anything that can be mathematically modeled". An interesting consequence of this level concerns the morality of simulating a suffering mind. At this level of multiverse, simulating a suffering mind doesn't cause that suffering to occur; It just allows observation of that suffering, which already exists.

I've been wanting to create a "quantum life insurance" business. I would buy a quantum hardware RNG, and every day generate a few hundred megabytes of random data. I would then run that data as an executable on my computer, and see if I had discovered strong ai. If I had, I'd ask it to develop the ability to scan and simulate human minds, and I'd upload the minds of my subscribers. It seems like this should actually work if the level III many-worlds interpretation is correct, but would be unnecessary under the level IV model.