Not terribly convincing arguments, but we have a 2013 Prius and a 2005 Mercedes C240. We are soon selling the latter and really want an EV, or at the least, another hybrid.

My wife made the comment that she dislikes the sound and the smell of starting our Mercedes in the garage. I agree. I enjoy driving our Prius more, much for that reason. All things being equal, the electric car is a better driving experience. If the price and range are comparable, it's a no-brainer.

steve:

ok... so here's my take.

I'm rounding the corner on a three year lease of a Nissan Leaf. I have loved the car. It has worked particularly well for us because it is ONLY my commuter car. We have a van for road trips and anything long distance. Range anxiety is a real thing - but disappears after a few months. I regularly get 90-100 miles out of a charge, but rarely wear it all the way out like that. In the winter, with heaters blowing, and all freeway (the worst mileage for EVs) I rolled 78 miles with still 8 or 9% left in the battery. The new Leaf has an even larger battery option (30kWh up from 24kWh).

When I originally leased the thing, gas was pushing $4/gallon, so it was even more sexy. Now that fuel is sub $2, it's a little less so.

The Leaf is expensive to insure. Even though federal and state incentives bring the purchase price down... insurance companies still zing you for the whole amount. And I think they're more nervous about new tech than you are.

And charging stations? They're actually nowhere in Denver. There are a few, but they are often in disrepair or blocked in. I wish establishments that install them would stop putting them up close. I'd rather have to walk a few extra yards and have a high probability of being able to use them. Just plan on installing one at home, and ask your employer if you can access a plug somewhere at work (or if they're really cool - they probably get a tax incentive to install a station).

I won't do another EV this time around... but that's less about the cars and more about my personal home situation (kid getting a license soon - he'll be expensive enough on a beatdown old corolla).

I hope Tesla gets it right. 200miles in a $30k EV will be a game changer.


posted 2795 days ago