Welcome to Hubski.   We share good ideas and conversation here.   Login or Join Us!
Ask Hubski: Is Obama a leftist, a centrist or to the right? What makes you think this?

Senator Obama quickly rose to national prominence in a political environment that couldn't have been better tailored to his rise. Candidate Obama was able to successfully communicate a message of change and hope for a future that seemed to be forged out of progressive ideas. When you heard him talk it was as if we'd all be driving cars powered by Doc Browns Mr. Fusion, we'd have accountability in our economic system and the most ethical governance in the history of man.

Has President Obama been as progressive as he campaigned to be, as transformative as you had hoped? Has the reality of governance forced a more moderate hand? Has his naiveté forced a more right leaning hand? Or is he just a lefty, progressive socialist?

Recently cliffelam, mk and b_b were having a discussion regarding this and I'm curious what you all think? Where does Obama, now that we have a term to look back on, fall on the political spectrum?

I'll quote b_b who said in jest regarding his policies:

    He's ended the Bush tax cuts, restored the Glass-Steagall Act, enacted Gay Marriage nationwide, ended the wars and closed Gitmo. Edit: He also stopped No Child Left behind and doubled science funding. Yippee!

-Pretty hard to call him a "leftie". From where I stand he seems pretty smack dab in the middle ---in an opportunistic way. But I'd like to know why I'm wrong or what the other opinions out there are. We are entering in to what will be a very exciting political climate imo.

Fire away!



by dbingham 397 days ago  ·  link
I don't think it has anything to do with him being centrist or "leaning" to the right. He's a progressive for sure. But he can only get done that which congress allows. And congress has been pretty damned obstructive.

I would say Obama is a pragmatic progressive. If you don't see him reaching for more, it's because he knows there's no way in hell he's gonna get it yet. So he reaches for less, things he thinks he can get. And then once he gets them, looks for ways to make the next step. He plays a very long chess game. We're criticizing him for sacrificing a bunch of pieces half way through. I'm still willing to give him the benefit of the doubt and see what the end game looks like.

by thenewgreen 396 days ago  ·  link
Didn't Clinton have a republican congress to deal with too? Was he also seen as being too much of an appeaser while in office and as having no back bone or was he seen as a unifier? Sincere question.
by dbingham 396 days ago  ·  link
Clinton instituted Don't Ask, Don't Tell, oversaw the repeal of Glass-Steagal, and failed to completely make any progress on Health Care. He was, also, impeached by his Republican opponents.

And that was all with a Republican opposition that was not nearly so obstructionist, experienced, insane or entrenched as the one Obama faces today. In Clinton's day, Fox News had not yet become the bastion of right wing propaganda that it is today, there were some campaign finance laws in place, Republicans had not yet perfected their use of the filibuster to completely shutdown the government and there was no Tea Party.

by thenewgreen 395 days ago  ·  link
Very valid, particularly the Tea Party and the Fox News points. It's definitely a different environment. I think it's unprecedented to have either of the party say that they essentially "hope the president fails" in general terms.
by mk 396 days ago  ·  link
I would say that he is a progressive in words but a centrist in action, sometimes a right-leaning one. IMO it's stupid we have to call equality for gays 'progressive'. It's right and decent. Obama doest score progressive points with me for the good he has done there. And with that aside, he could be a moderate Republican based on his record. Well, a Reagan type Republican, not the Tea Party stuff.
by b_b 397 days ago  ·  link
Hell I'd settle for an old fashioned Flux Capacitor at this point.


about hubski  ·  faq  ·  rss  ·  tmi  ·  twitter  ·  buttons  ·  tools  ·  arc  ·  privacy & terms  ·  login