Welcome to Hubski.   We share good ideas and conversation here.   Login or Join Us!
The Cost Of Creativity

by NotPhil · #culture
posted 403 days ago · shared by: 12
The cycle of innovations has to constantly accelerate, with each breakthrough providing a shorter reprieve.


by katakowsj 402 days ago  ·  link  
Well said mk. As you are my brother, and the person that creatively revealed to me that I have a low grade glioma (brain tumor) as the cause of my seizures rather than stress-induced tension or a small dwarf living in my stomach, as I was ready to believe if someone in authority told me. I will now be receiving the world's best possible treatment for that glioma.

You are a great guy, especially considering how creatively I innovated problems for you when we were yournger, but more importantly you have been creative and innovative in your approach to solving the problems associated with cancer and stroke through your research at Henry Ford Hospital. Research that intersected ideally at the crossroads of the currently best known solution to a problem I now posess.

In relation to this article, I do see a great hope for the future of human creativity. Creativity, in solving problems, creates other residual problems. I expect that with the removal of part of my right temporal lobe, I will see some temporary and residual problems in my life. The neuro-oncologist, and neurosurgeon have both made me aware of the likely outcomes. In my ability to creatively view the likely outcomes of my future, I am also consciously choosing to favor the residual problems over the primary ones by far. Without creative medical intervention, my primary problems are expected to be: increasing seizure frequency, possible death or injury to me or others from an untimely seizure, certainty of increased tumor aggressiveness without ever having direct pathology of said tumor material, and accepting that choosing inaction will most certainly lead to a shorter and lower quality for my remaining life. From speaking with the experts in gliomas, as well as my communications with others in the four days since I've been aware, I am pretty firmly convinced that human civilization is at a tipping point with creativity sharing, the likes of which have never before been seen on earth. The ability that a person like me has to share the amount of information I've traded in the last four days, about a potential life-threatening condition, has only confirmed to me further that creativity is everything. We are traders of creativity and information. We trade creative solutions to creatively born problems.

Like you, I enjoy the beauty of Michigan's Upper Penninsula. We would be able to enjoy it if it was truly only old growth forest. We could not get there, but we can and that's what makes it special. Similarly, I also enjoy writing this post more than others I've written in the past. My creative thinking about what the rest of my life may or may not look like has given me perspective of life farther from the "treadmill of problems" than ever before.

Thank you brother.

-Jeff

*I would guess that the cost in watts of this email transmission is far more efficient than the amount of energy it would take to cut a field to feed a horse, to pulp the trees and bleach the paper, to ship the india ink, from Oakland County to Detroit.

by mk 402 days ago  ·  link
No. Thank you, brother.

Watts be damned, you are worth them.

Now excuse me while I go cry a bit.

by steve 402 days ago  ·  link
dang it... you made me cry at work.

Jeff - thoughts and prayers your direction - like - all I have.

by katakowsj 402 days ago  ·  link
I look forward to my current situation as one of the best creative adventures that we may have together.

In addition, please disregard what I said when you grabbed some extra Upper Penninsula white pines, hemp rope, cinder blocks, and chain to whip up an actual working trebuchet on the shoreline of Lake Superior that one time.

Your creative energy easily saw beyond the limitations I placed on the situation. It wasn't until we had that damned trebuchet together that I realized that day at the beach that could easily have been ordinary and forgotten instead became one that I'll remember forever. Plus it made for a cool beach fire days later. Hot dogs and all. Thanks again.

Of course, someone could have been killed as that 30 pound stone travelled some distance into the lake. The likelyhood of that was miniscule and the I think the entire collatteral damage of that creative excercise was someone getting a pinched finger. The incredible value of that creative endeavor, the teamwork, and trust built is something I'd pinch my finger for any day.

This is quite a feeling. I trust you completely.

Jeff

by mk 402 days ago  ·  link
    Of course, someone could have been killed as that 30 pound stone travelled some distance into the lake. The likelyhood of that was miniscule and the I think the entire collatteral damage of that creative excercise was someone getting a pinched finger. The incredible value of that creative endeavor, the teamwork, and trust built is something I'd pinch my finger for any day.

I won't ever forget it either. I'll have to dig up the pictures and post them.

I remember our biggest mistake was using old jeans for the sling. :) Luckily they didn't give out on the backswing and send the stone into the neighbor's cottage. If we go for trebuchet 2.0, I'm sure we can get quite a bit further into the lake.

by katakowsj 402 days ago  ·  link
Trebuchet 2.0? It's on like Donkey Kong bro. Don't forget, I've got weeks of semi-sedentary recovery to creatively plot out and expand on our last monstrosity. It could very well turn out that glioma is the least of my future safety concerns.
by thenewgreen 401 days ago  ·  link
Today I learned what a Trebuche is, thanks for that. I had always just referred to them as catapults but now I can be more specific. Best of luck with your recovery Jeff.
by b_b 402 days ago  ·  link
I want wish you all the best of luck. I know the men who will be handling your treatment. They are professionals of the absolute highest standard; there's nothing they can't do that others can. Its a bitter irony that you would be stricken with this disease, given mk's relationship to it. Your brother is a good friend and colleague of mine, so I will look forward to hearing good news from him.
by katakowsj 396 days ago  ·  link
Ben. Thank you. It's been nice meeting you. One of the positives of a messy situation. Having spoken with you, my brother, and the staff of the Hermelin Tumor Team has been an eye opening experience. I never quite realized until two Thursday's ago how many limitiations I had been placing on the human experience and our ability to find solutions to the problems we encounter. I have been given, what I feel, is a rare glimpse of human ingenuity that so often gets lost in the din of our daily lives. Currently, I hope to hold this perspective as strongly as I can. It is my goal to shed as much light on the successes that such fine individuals as yourself have been setting me up for all along. If there are any specifics to which I can be helpful, please let me know immediately. On the contrary, please let me know if it is helpful to shut my yapper at any time. According to my wife, and some handy brain and behavior resources, some of my expressive "filters" have been affected, at least temporarily. The changes seem small to me so far. My wife has noticed some, but I expect some adjustments will definitely take place. Overall, the news is good. Relatively small and welcome opportunity costs are associated with my improved outlook. It all seems to relate back to economics in some way. Unlimited wants versus limited resources. Or, as the Stones said it so well, "You can't always get what you want...but if you try sometimes, you just might find, you get what you need." Gettying a bit sappy. Brain filter back on. Thank you.

Jeff

by katakowsj 402 days ago  ·  link
In my conversations with the fine human beings that will be handling my treatment, I have gained a new perspective about what is possible through creativity. Surgery and the "cancer" word aside, I've can see that my ulitimate future outcomes are hardly different than anyone else I know. I've just got a little work to do starting Thursday. I am in the very best of hands.

Before I walked into the office and met my help last Friday, I could not have expected to feel as fortuitous as I do now. Both gentlemen clearly demonstrated their expertise in gliomas, but more importantly, demonstrated just as clearly, that my problem and their solutions were matched as well as anyone could ever expect.

I tend to feel stronger that people are creativity traders more than ever before.

by mk 403 days ago  ·  link
It's interesting, but I wonder if it is true. We need more watts, but do we create those watts with less waste over time? We aren't eating plankton. Solar, wind and nuclear power are great ways to generate watts with little disruption of our ecosystem.

I live in Michigan. If you visited the state 200 years ago, it would have been covered in old growth forests. If you visited it 100 years ago, it would be dominated by clear-cut fields. Many of those fields have returned to forest, especially in the Upper Peninsula. I'm not sure if there isn't some balance to the equation. Without immigration, population growth in the US would be negative, and watts are relatively cheap.

by b_b 401 days ago  ·  link
This piece has potential to be interesting philosophy, but it is garbage science. Watts aren't a unit of energy, so most of his writing is fundamentally incorrect. This seems strange to me coming from what I gather is a science journalist who interviewed a physicist for the piece . This distinction matters; it isn't just semantics, nor is it trivial. Energy is power integrated over time. Saying we use higher wattage is only meaningful if we know the time spent using the power. Otherwise it is nonsense. It is a disgrace to not make this distinction in a piece about creativity. If you drive a truck that gets 15 mpg, and I drive a hybrid that gets 50 mpg, are you using more gas than me? Who knows? I may have a 40 mile drive to work, and you have a 1 mile drive. The same goes for energy an power. As a derived purely derived measurement, power cannot tell is much on its own. There is no such thing as 250 watts of energy. He may have something important or interesting to say, but its not clear from his writing. Is this average power? Peak power? What?

As an aside, the discussion sparked by this post was well more interesting and thoughtful that the piece itself.

by mk 401 days ago  ·  link
My impression was that he was using watts as J/s. -That this is the average power needed to run a particular lifestyle. Like a living American is equivalent to a 11000 watt bulb (turned on).

So, I guess that would be about 9.5 x 10^8 joules per day?

I agree that it's poor language choice to say 'needs x watts'. Maybe 'consumes energy at a rate of x watts'?

by b_b 401 days ago  ·  link
The problem is that he never defines if we're talking about average power or peak power (we have to assume on or the other--and you what happens when you assume). When you're running the microwave and the air conditioner while your wife is drying her hair, that's not the same as at night when you're asleep and everything but the refrigerator is off; its probably orders of magnitude different. 11,000 watts is a hell of a lot of power (its a little less than 15 hp, for all you anglophiles). But even if 11,000 is our average power, its not really an issue--if we can extract energy from the sun efficiently. The amount of energy that falls on the Earth every day is essentially infinite compared to our usage. There is no reason why the sun can't support 7 billion blue whales.

Either way, there is no way a science journalist should make such a grievous error; it renders his article misleading to most of his readers, and nonsense to the rest.

by katakowsj 400 days ago  ·  link
Sounds to me that a creative solution is truly in order. Our journalist did demonstrate the cost of his creative endeavour to expand our current understanding of the world. He also created a discussion that is interesting and personally relevant to me.

Due to several creative people I know and love, and a few more creative people that I've met, paths have been revealed to me that may likely enable me to beat a brain tumor that, left alone, will certainly end me. Creative solutions, ideas at first, were shared, imagined, revised, and acted on to instead give me, a 38 year-old, trained to teach middle school-aged students about math, science, and themselves, what I feel is the best chance at survival anyone in my place could possibly have.

Of course, the cost of this creativity will give me a nasty headache, some temporarily muddled thoughts, a small chance of reduced vision on my left side, but I will gladly accept the costs of this creativity. I also see some amazing possibilities for all people as we move forward as a society of people creatively trading problems, solutions, and agreeing on acceptable costs. Is that what this is really about?

I better get some sleep. It should help me negate some of the opportunity costs of tomorrow's initial decision.

Thanks again Mark.

Jeff

by mk 398 days ago  ·  link
No thanks ever needed. I'm just happy that everything went as well as it did. Yes, the aches might have been much worse than anticipated, but no vision loss, and it's incredible that no deficits are apparent after such a resection!

It's absurd how distracted we get, and how this strips away what isn't substantial. That's one thing those costs are buying. I've been given a perspective that I didn't have, and won't soon forget. We definitely did get that out of this.

We are going forward, brother! We have more to create, and that is an awesome thing.

Thank you, Jeff.

by katakowsj 396 days ago  ·  link
Brain tumors have an incredible way of getting a person's attention. It's hard to ignore seizures and other involuntary actions. Quite the opposite of creativity as we speak of it. It has though, spurred on some creative endeavours to continue my life and revealed a convergence of creative thinking than I would have previously not predicted to exist. The possiblilities of what I imagine can be accomplished within our lifetimes seems to have very few limits as far as those nasty glioma brain cells gone wrong are concerned. Nasty little bastards if you ask me. I expect they'll get what's due to them eventually. I look forward to contributing where I can.

Jeff



about hubski  ·  faq  ·  rss  ·  tmi  ·  twitter  ·  buttons  ·  tools  ·  arc  ·  privacy & terms  ·  login