a thoughtful web.
Good ideas and conversation. No ads, no tracking.   Login or Take a Tour!
comment by cgod
cgod  ·  1397 days ago  ·  link  ·    ·  parent  ·  post: Voting Age

I think the opportunity to combine participation in elections with high school civics classes is pretty compelling. In some schools it won't amount to much, in others it would become a major preoccupation.

I think vote 16 would cause a significant increase in government and politics participation by young people.

The real concerns and problems of youth are mostly ignored while at the same time protecting them guides a significant portion of legislation and regulation (for the children!) There is much talk in today's political arena (maybe most this talk happens a great deal more in liberal places like the Pacific NW) about giving voices to marginalized groups. I think young people are significantly marginalized. I know I never felt more marginalized than I did when I was 16 and often for good reason. My actions and motivations were closely scrutinized, there were few public places I wanted to be that I was allowed to be without suspicion (especially after dark).

I think if kids voted there is a greater chance politicians would feel greater accountability about providing desirable public goods that young people wanted. I think that there would be more scrutiny of how police interact with young people before it comes down to a cop ust shot a kid.

As a lobbying force they could become quite scary. They spend 5 days a week together, have plenty of free time and modern technology can easily connect a network of schools to mobilize

It is getting surprisingly and pleasently busy at the shop right now so I'll leave off here. I might have a few more thoughts but that's the gist of my thoughts.





kleinbl00  ·  1397 days ago  ·  link  ·  

To be clear, I'm not opposed to the idea, just curious as to the justification.

Where I grew up you could get a driver's license at fifteen if you passed a state-accredited driver's education course. I would think if you let everyone take the civics test when they apply for a driver's license or ID card you'd get plenty of takers, particularly if you tied it into something useful like the ability to buy cigarettes or sign yourself out as absent. Being 18 in high school is badass and if you could test into that you'd win.