a thoughtful web.
Good ideas and conversation. No ads, no tracking.   Login or Take a Tour!
comment by kleinbl00
kleinbl00  ·  2583 days ago  ·  link  ·    ·  parent  ·  post: David Brooks: The Unifying American Story

Sweet tapdancing christ has this mutherfucker not read Exodus? has he not read the Cliff's Notes for Exodus?

    The book of Exodus is full of social justice — care for the vulnerable, the equality of all souls.

THE BOOK OF EXODUS IS FULL OF PLAGUES, MUTHERFUCKER. It is the Kill Bill of biblical literature.

    It suggests that history is in the shape of an upward spiral.

It suggests that if God is on your side, genocide is A-OK.

    The Exodus narrative has pretty much been dropped from our civic culture. Schools cast off the Puritans as a bunch of religious fundamentalists.

They were one of thirteen colonies, Dave. The Carolinas weren't at all about fleeing Cromwell.

    It should be possible to revive the Exodus template, to see Americans as a single people trekking through a landscape of broken institutions. What’s needed is an act of imagination, somebody who can tell us what our goal is, and offer an ideal vision of what the country and the world should be.

It's like watching the Church Lady on shrooms.





lil  ·  2583 days ago  ·  link  ·  

There are many lenses one can see Exodus through. -- I'm not sure that the mass killing of the Egyptians or the removing of the existing populations of Canaan (a process continuing to this day) completely shutters the story Gorski is choosing to highlight:

    The Exodus story has six acts: first, a life of slavery and oppression, then the revolt against tyranny, then the difficult flight through the howling wilderness, then the infighting and misbehavior amid the stresses of that ordeal, then the handing down of a new covenant, a new law, and then finally the arrival into a new promised land and the project of building a new Jerusalem.

The difficulty and challenge is looking through both lenses at the same time, hoping that we are moving towards a story that can have liberation without genocide. Given the history of humans so far, it's a hard story to write.

kleinbl00  ·  2583 days ago  ·  link  ·  

There are many lenses one can see most of the bible through, no doubt. But to somehow imagine that - wait, where's that quote?

    For most of the past 400 years, Americans did have an overarching story. It was the Exodus story.

I mean, (1) "for particularly narrow interpretations of 'Americans'" (2) it's the same story that makes plague blankets and death marches okay. "I'm oppressed, it's payback time."

Having read up extensively on the Puritans, what they believed and what they were fleeing, I for one long for a country that never attempts to emulate them in any way, shape or form and I'm a middle-class, middle-aged white male.