a thoughtful web.
Good ideas and conversation. No ads, no tracking.   Login or Take a Tour!
comment by jadedog
jadedog  ·  2774 days ago  ·  link  ·    ·  parent  ·  post: CRISPR Could Usher in a New Era of Delicious GMO Foods - The Atlantic

    In Sweden, Jansson is no stranger to unease over genetic engineering. His colleagues recently returned from a conference where activists flung cow dung and eggs at scientists. The CRISPR-edited cabbage he grew he actually got from researchers outside Sweden, who did not want their names or even their country revealed, fearing backlash from environmental activists.

    [edited out content]

    Too much of it can make humans sick, and his cabbage was, remember, not originally bred for cultivation.

    His stomach didn’t feel great after, Jansson confessed— “as if I had spicy food at an Indian restaurant.” But CRISPR, he suggested, could help with that.

I'm not seeing the point. He removed a gene, calling that process CRISPR instead of the dreaded GMO. It sounds genetically modified. It's modifying a gene. It sounds like he's getting around the FDA classification at the moment because he's not adding any DNA?

The environmentalists are already in a rage about it. Scientists aren't backing it. He got sick over his own creation.

The commercial prospects for this don't look good.





markentingh  ·  2773 days ago  ·  link  ·  

stop freaking out. Jesus. It's just a gene in a vegetable. Oh no, we're all going to die because the genes are edited. Did you know that everything you eat affects your DNA? Everything you consume modifies your body in some way. Also, don't you remember that we all die within 80 to 120 years of our lifespan? So who cares. Maybe some day they'll be able to make broccoli taste like cotton candy for people like you.

jadedog  ·  2773 days ago  ·  link  ·  

Haha. Welcome to Hubski as of an hour ago. Did you join just to tell me not to freak out?

My comment wasn't personal to me. I'm not "freaking out". I don't have personal feelings about GMO either way. I just summarized the article. The only part I added was that commercial prospects don't look good based on how it's getting received. This new process will likely have a PR problem to become commercially viable.