a thoughtful web.
Good ideas and conversation. No ads, no tracking.   Login or Take a Tour!
comment by AshleyR
AshleyR  ·  3056 days ago  ·  link  ·    ·  parent  ·  post: New Hubski Users (and old), what are your hobbies?

Hmm... listening to music (and writing reviews), writing music... programming (though I started developing Android apps last year, but didn't come up with any use for it, tried HTML/CSS but didn't like it much).

Lately I got drawn to movies and writing. Fashion has been an interest for quite some time.





user-inactivated  ·  3056 days ago  ·  link  ·  

I still struggle to understand why some people put "listening to music" as a hobby. It sounds like a petty excuse for having one: most of all people on the planet listen to music in some capacity; whether it's great or small doesn't matter. It's like putting "watching TV" or "shopping for groceries" under hobbies: pointless.

Your writing reviews for the music you listen to, though? That's a hobby. Writing music? Another one. Programming? There you go. All are proper activities in which not the absolute majority of the developed world is involved. Hobbies are activities that distinguish you, that make you you, and I can't grasp how doing that thing that 90% of the developed world population does makes you any different.

Do explain if you can. I'm having a hard time wrapping my head around music listening being a hobby.

_refugee_  ·  3056 days ago  ·  link  ·  

I think it depends on the level of investment being put into the activity - here, listening to music.

I had one friend who was very, very into music. He read music blogs, he knew all the names of all the members of his favorite bands (and there were many), he listened to TONS of current albums, and he went to a lot of shows as well. When he listened to music, I could tell from our conversations that he listened intently and retained a great deal more about a single song from a single listen than I often did after listening to a song several times. I think that was partially because, as a person interested in music, he was listening for and able to hear a lot of finer details that the lay-listener didn't know or care to listen for/hear. I think it was also because he was actively listening, not just passively turning on a track and letting it play while he did other things in the background.

It's like - I hear people talk about "production." "This track was minimally produced and has a very raw sound," or "This track is very produced," or more specifically, talking about styles of production - like Dr. Dre and what makes him a great producer and why.

I can kind of hear production. I can tell when a track is more produced over less. But I am very hard pressed to talk about details of production, or production style, or what it is that makes Dre so great at being a music producer or how he does it. I think people who really care about music and are really good at it, though, listen on a different level and are able to differentiate between things like quality of underlying vocals, quality of the melody/bass line/drum line/etc, and where "production" starts and what it does in a given song.

So I would think someone who writes music reviews would listen to music more on that elevated kind of level, and can see why it could be considered a hobby, because it would be a lot more active than what the average person does.

Then again I see your point, where saying "Listening to music" is a hobby is similar to saying "I like to have fun" when someone asks what you do in your spare time. Well, yes. Everyone likes to have fun. Liking to have fun says little to nothing about a person. It is how they find their fun that is more interesting and important.

user-inactivated  ·  3056 days ago  ·  link  ·  

I see what you mean. Your friend's example would be a great interest in music, though, not merely a hobby of listening to it, would it not?

AshleyR  ·  3056 days ago  ·  link  ·  

    Do explain if you can.

My pleasure! Let's go by parts:

    most of all people on the planet listen to music in some capacity

That's right. If their ears work, people listen to music.

    whether it's great or small doesn't matter. It's like putting "watching TV" or "shopping for groceries

I get you. You're talking about the casual listeners. These are the people who listen to whatever music is playing on the radio at the moment or whatever is popular right now. When I'm talking to someone and they say "oh, I like all kinds of music" and they don't go in detail (genres, bands, etc), I identify that person as a casual listener. No problem with that, this is how most people start.

After that, you get into a single genre. I live in a place where those who care about music are crazy about rock and heavy metal. They listen to the most famous bands of their preferred subgenres. You could say this is the second level of the casual listener, along with the die-hard fan of a single band.

    All are proper activities in which not the absolute majority of the developed world is involved. Hobbies are activities that distinguish you, that make you you, and I can't grasp how doing that thing that 90% of the developed world population does makes you any different.

Hmm... I think you should take a look at this list I shared with yellowoftops.

This is the difference between casual listeners and people who love listening to music. I started that list around 2 years ago. I usually go through the entire artist's discography, listening to the albums front to back. It used to be a single genre for the first 100-150 albums, but then I felt an urge to diversify a bit. Now, I listen to around 2-3 albums a day: if you look at the end of the list, you'll see that right now I'm oscillating between metal and disco.

About doing something that 90% of the developed world population does... well, we get a lot of great music with each passing day, and one simply cannot listen to ALL the music out there. I tried finding some bands in common with the people I used to talk about music, but it wasn't of any use: all the bands I knew were unknown to them, and they didn't know any of the bands I liked. After the 300 albums mark, I just stopped name-dropping the bands I liked, it's just so many! As time went by, I noticed my taste got broader and more specialized.

In closing, it classifies as a hobby for me because I get a craving for new music whenever I stop looking for new stuff. And there are the "oh, there's nothing interesting out there" cycles every 3 months.

user-inactivated  ·  3053 days ago  ·  link  ·  

Thank you for such great detail in your reply.

I understand what you mean. Therefore, here's a question to you:

I like listening to music so much I do it everyday, for as long as I'm near a PC. I listen to both popular soundmakers and those less popular - not because popularity matters but because I enjoy the sound the produce at the given moment. I have a collection of music that's gigabytes long because I have varying tastes and prefer FLACs to 320 kbps MP3s due to their superior sound quality. I never talk about liking listening to music but I'd love for someone to express exactly what gets them high in the music they listen to. Which category of listeners, according to you, do I belong to?

AshleyR  ·  3051 days ago  ·  link  ·  

Looking at these excerpts:

    I like listening to music so much I do it everyday, for as long as I'm near a PC. I listen to both popular soundmakers and those less popular - not because popularity matters but because I enjoy the sound the produce at the given moment.

    I have a collection of music that's gigabytes long because I have varying tastes and prefer FLACs to 320 kbps MP3s due to their superior sound quality

    I never talk about liking listening to music but I'd love for someone to express exactly what gets them high in the music they listen to.

And especially at this one:

    I still struggle to understand why some people put "listening to music" as a hobby. It sounds like a petty excuse for having one: most of all people on the planet listen to music in some capacity; whether it's great or small doesn't matter. It's like putting "watching TV" or "shopping for groceries" under hobbies: pointless.

I can say that you care about music. You're definitely not a casual listener. And since you prefer a hi-fi audio format (and perhaps have the gear to play hi-fi music), I'm gonna take a risk and say that you are an audiophile.

As I wrote before, casual listening is the starting point. There are many routes one can take in listening to music. You can learn to play an instrument (if you don't know already), review music, play it on bleeding-edge equipment, blast it from your car... it's up to you.

user-inactivated  ·  3047 days ago  ·  link  ·  

The reason I asked was to clarify the classification you put forth, as well as to get the fresh outside look at my internal workings. Now I see clearer that, indeed, I may have been mistaken in my rash judgement on the matter.

That being said, I still disagree with "listening to music" being a hobby. It doesn't fit into my head's definition of a hobby - which is not to say others can't consider it such, and since so many do, I'm very curious still. Why call it a hobby and not an interest (which, in my head, it clearly is)?

user-inactivated  ·  3056 days ago  ·  link  ·  

What is your review site?

AshleyR  ·  3056 days ago  ·  link  ·  

I just write for myself. Didn't feel like publishing anything yet. It's usually some short notes (~100 words, the longest one has 300 words) on what I liked about the albums and what I thought didn't sound so well. I do that in an Evernote file. I can show you if you want, but it's in Portuguese.

I tried starting a music review blog before, but it just took out the fun for me.

People suggested that I should start a Youtube channel. I'm considering it, thought I don't want to expose myself.

In conclusion, I don't feel like the world needs my opinion on the music I like/dislike.

user-inactivated  ·  3056 days ago  ·  link  ·  

My Portuguese is severely limited by my inability to speak it.

AshleyR  ·  3056 days ago  ·  link  ·  
user-inactivated  ·  3055 days ago  ·  link  ·  

Yeah. You have good taste in music. Anyone that listens to Powerman 5000 and Prince on the same list is all right with me.

Prince - Cream.