a thoughtful web.
Good ideas and conversation. No ads, no tracking.   Login or Take a Tour!
comment by demure
demure  ·  3172 days ago  ·  link  ·    ·  parent  ·  post: Hubnomic 1: Ruleset CREATIVE-KEYCHAIN - Rules on beginning

Ruleset proposition WEIRD-QUORUM

Terms defined:

  ruleset number as N in form: N.m.o
  rule number as m in form: N.m.o
  subrule as required as o in form: N.m.o
  ruleset proposition: unratified ruleset
  ratified ruleset: ruleset already approved
  immutable and mutable rules: as stated on the Wikipedia page about nomic games
  player: human user of Hubski subscribed to #hubnomic
  vote: statement of support for the ratification of a ruleset proposition
  shall: must, required, mandatory
  parent post, child comment.
2.1 all new ruleset propositions shall be created under the parent post of the existing ratified ruleset (eg Hubnomic 2 development should exist under Hubnomic 1 to reduce post spamming)

2.2 all new ruleset propositions shall be incremented plus one from the parent post (eg all ruleset propositions on this post should start with 2)

2.3 ratification of ruleset propositions shall occur 96 hours after the post of the next ruleset under the following conditions:

2.3.1 voting shall occur on a specific version of a ruleset proposition, i.e. changes may be discussed but players should not vote for a child comment containing a ruleset proposition unless they agree with it in its current form

2.3.2 changes to a player's ruleset proposition shall be at the discretion of the player proposing the proposition

2.3.3 changes to a player's ruleset proposition can be made at any point but votes shall count for the ruleset which is quoted in a vote

2.4 votes shall contain the word "Ratify" under a quote of the version of the ruleset proposition they wish to ratify

2.5 ruleset propositions shall contain a unique identifying term at the top which shall change if the proposition changes to make vote counting easy (i.e. ADJECTIVE-NOUN)

2.6 at the end of the 96 hour period marked by the post time posted in ratified rulesets, the ruleset proposition contained in a child comment with the most votes counted using the above method shall be ratified

2.7 ratification shall occur when the next post by entity hubnomic is created in #hubnomic with an incremented ruleset number.

2.8 terms used in rulesets and ruleset propositions shall be defined in the post unless the term already exists.

2.9 edits shall be detailed below the post

edits: added 2.9, changed wording from 'will', 'must', and 'should' to all use 'shall' per my own rules...





demure  ·  3172 days ago  ·  link  ·  

I like this one, myself. Ratify.

user-inactivated  ·  3172 days ago  ·  link  ·  

Did you just cast vote 2 votes for your own proposal? Not accusing, just wondering, I know it's all general chaos at this point.

user-inactivated  ·  3172 days ago  ·  link  ·  

I agree with you. Seconded.

demure  ·  3172 days ago  ·  link  ·  

no, hubnomic doesn't vote. If you meant that I posted "ratify", well, we haven't determined how voting works yet :P and right now CREATIVE-KEYCHAIN stipulates 'consensus', so I am letting people know I'm voting for my own proposal :)

thewoodenaisle  ·  3172 days ago  ·  link  ·  

FYI, you repeated 2.4 twice.

demure  ·  3172 days ago  ·  link  ·  

got it, thanks!

ChaosWaffle  ·  3171 days ago  ·  link  ·  

Would the ruleset owner be allowed to change the ruleset via editing, or would the revised ruleset be reposted?

regardless of the slight confusion, this seems the best thought out set of rules so far:

Ratify.

user-inactivated  ·  3172 days ago  ·  link  ·  

Overall, this seems to make the most sense to start off with, and seems the most comprehensive. So: seconded.