a thoughtful web.
Good ideas and conversation. No ads, no tracking.   Login or Take a Tour!
comment by lil
lil  ·  3609 days ago  ·  link  ·    ·  parent  ·  post: On Jumping to Conclusions

You can be against something with thoughtful argument (but that takes thought and argument, intelligence, research and patience), with irony (which is often misunderstood), and tongue-in-cheekiness (which is frequently taken literally). You can also be against something by ignoring it. veen's statement, reinforced by kleinbl00 (who weirdly enhanced my dreams all night):

    civility is a design choice as much as a cultural choice
is intriguing and as true for web design as it is for urban design.

This would be another great slogan:

    Hubski: Where civility is a design choice




veen  ·  3608 days ago  ·  link  ·  

I would alter it to: Hubski. Civility by design.

Maybe it's dwelling on definitions, but I much prefer motto or philosophy over slogan. Slogan seems to me like something a marketingteam has to add afterwards, while a philosophy is a guiding principle on which new decisions can be based.

lil  ·  3169 days ago  ·  link  ·  

Hubski. Civility by Design has got to go on a sticker.

veen  ·  3169 days ago  ·  link  ·  

I will definitely bug insomniasexx about it tomorrow.

insomniasexx  ·  3169 days ago  ·  link  ·  

You just did. And it's totally not tomorrow yet!

thenewgreen  ·  3608 days ago  ·  link  ·  

As you can imagine, we put a lot of time and thought in to the "motto" for Hubski (I too dislike the term slogan). At first I had wanted to have it read: Hubski -are you thoughtful? Because I wanted people to feel challenged by it. I wanted to let people know that there was an expectation. mk wisely, and strongly disagreed and preferred "a thoughtful web" which is what is there next to "Hubski" when you are logged out.

I like "Hubski -Civility by design" and hope the site can continue to live up to such a lofty philosophy.

veen  ·  3608 days ago  ·  link  ·  

I agree with mk, I much prefer 'a thoughtful web' because the other one sounds almost threatening: are you even thoughtful?!!?!

A true motto has to be in Latin, so if I translated it correctly (my Latin is rough) it should be in civilitate consilium, which can mean both civility through design as civility through wisdom (consilium can mean both plan, wisdom as judgement.

mk  ·  3607 days ago  ·  link  ·  

thenewgreen:

    As you can imagine, we put a lot of time and thought in to the "motto" for Hubski (I too dislike the term slogan).

While that's true, we actually put most of the time and thought into after the fact. I put up "a thoughtful web" with only a little consideration. Over time we have asked ourselves whether or not we should say something different, if anything at all. We keep coming back to it. I like that it works on more than one level, and that it begs interpretation.

I don't view Hubski users as customers, and I don't intend to encourage that kind of relationship unnecessarily. There is no doubt that we are providing a kind of service here with the site, but I want to create a new space, and I don't see why at the same time we can't carve out a little bit of new space in an economic sense as well. In fact, the latter might be necessary if we are to succeed at the first.

On a somewhat related tangent, I find it bizarre how in this day, companies will relate to their customers in ways that their customers wouldn't dare relate to each other. Take radio advertisements, for example. By and large (at least in the US) radio advertisements often employ a sense of humor that only a genuine idiot might appreciate. They are loud, obnoxious, and not funny. A terribly offensive and degrading interaction has become normalized in radio advertising simply because it works.

I never want to start talking about you all behind closed doors as if you were somehow different than me. The day that we start doing that is the day that Hubski starts to die. The site might grow as a result, but Hubski will wither and die.

ButterflyEffect  ·  3607 days ago  ·  link  ·  

    By and large (at least in the US) radio advertisements often employ a sense of humor that only a genuine idiot might appreciate.

This is certainly true of larger, syndicated radio stations. It's appealing to the lowest common denominator and taking the easiest route to a quick dollar. Plus, if you're the radio station or underwriter it's easier to sell. Most of the ads run on those kind of radio stations aren't exactly high-brow businesses anyway.

I actually have a decent amount of experience with creating, marketing, and running radio advertisements and have been fortunate enough to do so through a college-station in a mid-sized market. We avoid advertisements like you have described at all costs.

thenewgreen  ·  3607 days ago  ·  link  ·  

    While that's true, we actually put most of the time and thought into after the fact.
-True, true. I recall a list of words/phrases put together only to return to what was already there.

    I never want to start talking about you all behind closed doors as if you were somehow different than me
-I agree, I am first and foremost a hubskier. It would be a very sad thing if I felt otherwise. I think it was flagamuffin that recently said that he approaches each conversation on Hubski as if the other person likely knows more about the topic than he does. I too take this approach and I extend it to the understanding of the site itself. This place is special to me because of the collection of people that use it. For this reason, I think the hubski logo is perfect, I see the smaller dots as individuals and the larger one as the collective.

I don't see the users of Hubski as customers and I'll also never see them as a product.

    at the same time we can't carve out a little bit of new space in an economic sense as well. In fact, the latter might be necessary if we are to succeed at the first.
I'd like to hear more about these new ideas.
lil  ·  3608 days ago  ·  link  ·  

I added it to the slogan (motto, philosophy) page. This whole discussion about the effect of design on everything is fascinating.