Hi friends,

I wanted to know your views on this issue..

Some of my points

In Favor of abolishing it:

1. It is inhumane and uncivilized and against right to life and throwback to medieval practice

2. If innocent person is, by mistake, hanged, no amount of justice can be done

3. It doesn't act as deterrence

4. About 140 countries have abolished it, mainly in Europe

Against abolishing it:

1. It is given only in rarest of rare cases in case of heinous crimes

2. It confers right on victim, to justice

3. It acts as deterrence to some extent

4. For punishing masterminds behind international terrorism, it is required.

My points seem theoretical to some extent, I need some deeper insight on whether it should be retained or not, and a concrete stand on it..

I hope to get some help in this regard:)

lil:

    It confers right on victim, to justice
It depends on what you mean by justice.

    It acts as deterrence to some extent
I haven't seen any evidence of this. Have you? Does state-sanctioned murder teach people not to murder?

    About 140 countries have abolished it, mainly in Europe.
Mainly in the world. In North America 2/3 countries have abolished it.

What does USA, China, North Korea, Iran, and Saudia Arabia have in common?


posted 2687 days ago