a thoughtful web.
Good ideas and conversation. No ads, no tracking.   Login or Take a Tour!
comment
_refugee_  ·  2278 days ago  ·  link  ·    ·  parent  ·  post: What are your goals for 2018?

Hey so, just wondering...since you determined your habits/motivations were driven by that "rebel" behavior type, have you found your behavior seems to conform to that expectation formed by the quiz you took?

I think what I'm struggling with is understanding how being a rebel, and defying both your own and others' expectations for yourself, could be more positive as a personality trait than detrimental. I confess, I took the quiz and it says I'm an upholder; personally, I've always been very self-directed and driven, so the results jive - I'll hold off on snark about personality tests for the time being. I mention my natural tendency because it seems pretty directly oppositional to the "Rebel" type, and could be a large part of why I struggle to understand how a person could be a rebel type and also really achieve what he/she wants out of life.

So then I have to ask - if 'rebel' is really as hobbling a tendency as it seems to me - why would anyone get that result and say, "Oh, okay, that's me. Reactionary and distractable. I sure do want to stay that way," instead of trying to learn how to manage themselves and achieve their desires more effectively, not to mention proactively, than someone whose life is controlled by the desires of all others?

I mean, logically...wouldn't a rebel deny and act against the proscriptive results of a personality quiz? But then they'd be a conformist. Maybe you can't rebel against one thing without accidentally conforming to something else. I mean. Just saying. I'd think a true rebel would maybe have to be more erratic in behavior than anything else